Both the Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti Open Heart Pendant and the Cartier Love Bracelet are excellent choices, depending on budget and style preference. The Tiffany pendant is a more accessible entry point into designer jewelry with a classic, elegant design, while the Cartier Love Bracelet represents a significant investment in a high-end, iconic piece with a unique and secure design.
| Attribute | Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti Open Heart Pendant | Cartier Love Bracelet |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Tiffany & Co. | Cartier |
| Material | Available in sterling silver, 18k rose gold, 18k yellow gold, and platinum. Some versions include diamonds. | Typically 18k yellow gold, white gold, or rose gold. Platinum was previously offered but has been discontinued. Some versions include diamonds or other precious stones. |
| Design | The pendant features a heart-shaped design with an open center. The simple, evocative shape celebrates the spirit of love. | Created in 1969 by Aldo Cipullo, featuring a unisex "modern handcuff" design. It has a sleek, oval shape with visible screws. The design symbolizes an unbreakable bond. |
| Pendant/Bracelet Style | Pendant necklace | Rigid bangle, also available in cuff versions. |
| Target Gender | Not specified, but the design is versatile. | Unisex |
| Chain Length (if applicable) | Varies depending on the model. Common lengths include 16 inches, 18 inches, and adjustable lengths. | Not applicable, as it is a bangle. |
| Motif Size (if applicable) | Available in various sizes, including 11mm, 16mm, 22mm, 27mm, and 36mm. | Comes in small, classic, and medium sizes. |
| Closure Type | Lobster clasp or spring ring | Original models have two functional screws requiring a screwdriver to open and close. Newer models may have a single-screw closure system with a hinge or a hidden button with a tongue-and-groove setting. |
| Hallmarks/Authenticity Marks | Hallmarked with "Tiffany & Co.," "Peretti," and "925" or "750" (depending on the material). Some are also marked with "Spain". | Authentic bracelets have precise engravings including the Cartier signature, metal purity marks (e.g., "Au750" for 18K gold), a copyright symbol, and a serial number. The serial number should be consistent with Cartier's records. |
| Care Instructions | Not available | Clean regularly with a soft brush and lukewarm soapy water, then rinse and wipe with a soft cloth. Avoid wearing in wet or abrasive environments. Store individually in the original case. Cartier offers a polishing service. |
| Packaging | Arrives in a Tiffany Blue Box. The Blue Boxes and bags are made with paper from sustainable sources and recycled materials. Some listings mention a pouch. | Comes in a signature red Cartier box, with a shopping bag and gift card available. |
| Price Range | Prices vary widely depending on the material, size, and presence of diamonds. Examples from search results: Sterling silver: $550, 18k Rose Gold: $1,135 - $1,170, 18k Yellow Gold: $950, Diamond versions can retail for $24,000 | New Love Bracelets range from approximately $4,750 to $62,000, depending on the materials and presence of gemstones. Pre-owned bracelets can be found for as low as $4,050. |
| Ratings | Not available | Not available |
| Pros | Versatile design complements both casual and formal attire, Iconic design by Elsa Peretti, Reflects Tiffany & Co.'s quality standards, Suitable for gifting with Tiffany Blue Box packaging, Comfortable to wear, Pairs well with any style, Elegant and classic, Suitable for most occasions | Versatile design complements both casual and formal attire, Iconic piece with high-quality materials and exceptional craftsmanship, Generally light and comfortable for daily wear, Original screw system is very secure, Retains value well, Packaging suitable for gifting and storage |
| Cons | Sterling silver may develop small scratches from use, Some jewelry may need to be cleaned or buffed | Susceptible to scratches and scuffs, May require occasional polishing, Later versions of the clasp may sacrifice some security for convenience, Individuals with metal allergies should be aware of the specific alloys used |