Travel destinations: Cancun, Mexico vs. Maui, Hawaii
Quick Verdict
Cancun is a budget-friendly option with a lively atmosphere, while Maui offers a more luxurious and diverse experience at a higher cost.
- Cancun offers more affordable accommodation and a vibrant nightlife.
- Maui is more expensive but provides a wider range of water activities and unique cultural experiences.
- Both destinations are family-friendly and offer all-inclusive resort options.
Key features – Side-by-Side
| Attribute | Cancun, Mexico | Maui, Hawaii |
|---|---|---|
| Average Flight Duration | Around 6 hours 24 minutes from the U.S. | Not available |
| Average Cost Per Night | $88 (average paid), $118 (average), $221 (high season) | $500 (off-season average), $933 (peak season average), $536 (mid-range average) |
| All-Inclusive Resort Availability | Wide variety available | Available, some are 'inclusive' with meals/activities |
| Beach Quality | White sand beaches and turquoise waters | Variety of beaches with crystal-clear waters and soft sand; theft can be a problem |
| Water Activities | Snorkeling, diving, surfing, barrier reef | Snorkeling, diving, surfing, windsurfing, paddleboarding, kayaking, whale watching |
| Nightlife and Entertainment | Nightclubs, bars, live music, cultural performances | Bars, live music venues, luaus, stargazing |
| Family-Friendliness | Kids' clubs and activities available | Kids' clubs and activities available, calm beaches for young children |
| Cultural Attractions | Mayan archaeological sites, Museo Maya de Cancun | Haleakalā National Park, Lahaina Historic District, ʻĪao Valley State Monument, Alexander & Baldwin Sugar Museum |
| Safety and Security | Generally safe for tourists, exercise caution in crowded areas | Generally safe, but crime exists; ocean environment can pose dangers |
| Accessibility and Transportation | Accessible transportation available, taxis and rideshare recommended | Wheelchair-accessible buses and shuttle services available |
| Overall Cost (7-day trip) | Not available | $3,000-$8,000 per person |
Overall Comparison
Cost: Cancun wins; Activities: Maui wins; Family-Friendliness: Both good
Pros and Cons
Cancun, Mexico
Pros:
- White sand beaches
- Turquoise waters
- Wide variety of all-inclusive resorts
- Vibrant nightlife
- Family-friendly resorts and activities
- Opportunities for cultural immersion
- Clear ocean water suitable for swimming
- Diverse culinary scene
Cons:
- Can get crowded, especially during peak seasons
- Exercise caution in crowded areas or nightlife districts after dark
Maui, Hawaii
Pros:
- Variety of water activities
- Family-friendly environment
- Romantic options for couples
- Cultural and historical sites
- Accessible transportation options
Cons:
- High cost
- Theft can be a problem at beaches and parks
- Crowded beaches during peak season
- Food quality at resorts can vary
User Experiences and Feedback
Cancun, Mexico
What Users Love
- Variety of food options at resorts
- Ease of getting around with taxis or rideshare services
- Generally safe to walk around in tourist areas
- Good opportunities for cultural immersion
- Popular water activities like snorkeling and diving
- Suitable for families with young children
Common Complaints
- No major complaints reported.
Value Perception
- Cost of food, activities, and transportation is comparable to other similar destinations
Maui, Hawaii
What Users Love
- Calm and clear ocean water at Kamaole I & III beaches and Baby Beach
- Opportunities for cultural immersion through local markets and historical tours
- Popular water activities like snorkeling and diving at Molokini Crater
- Suitable for families with young children in areas like Wailea and Ka'anapali
- Unique experiences such as Secret Beach, Waihee Ridge Trail, and Makena Landing
Common Complaints
- Avoid beaches after sunset and be cautious in remote areas
- Maui is one of the more expensive Hawaiian Islands
Value Perception
- Renting a car is recommended for exploring the island