Train services: Japan Railway (Shinkansen) vs. Rocky Mountaineer
Quick Verdict
Shinkansen is ideal for efficient travel between cities, while Rocky Mountaineer offers a scenic and luxurious multi-day journey.
- Shinkansen is known for its speed and punctuality, while Rocky Mountaineer focuses on scenic views and a luxurious experience.
- Shinkansen has limited food and beverage options compared to Rocky Mountaineer's high-quality dining service.
- Rocky Mountaineer has potential delays and bus transfers, while Shinkansen is renowned for its punctuality.
Key features – Side-by-Side
| Attribute | Japan Railway (Shinkansen) | Rocky Mountaineer |
|---|---|---|
| Route Options and Destinations | Connects major cities on Honshu, Kyushu, and Hokkaido. Key routes: Tokaido, Sanyo, Tohoku, and Kyushu Shinkansen. New lines planned for Sapporo and Osaka. | Routes through the Canadian Rockies (Vancouver, Banff, Jasper, Lake Louise) and the USA (Moab, Utah to Denver, Colorado). Multi-day travel with overnight stays. |
| Ticket Pricing and Class Options | Base fare, Shinkansen supplement, and seat reservation fee. Classes: Ordinary, Green Car (business class), and Gran Class (first class). Discounts may be available. | SilverLeaf and GoldLeaf service levels. SilverLeaf Plus available on Rockies to the Red Rocks route. Pricing varies by route, service level, and time of year. |
| Onboard Amenities | Free Wi-Fi on most trains. Power outlets available. Restrooms, wheelchair-accessible toilets. Smoking prohibited. Multi-purpose rooms available. | Power outlets are available. Wi-Fi availability is not consistently mentioned. GoldLeaf: bi-level coaches with glass-dome windows, separate dining room, and outdoor viewing platform; SilverLeaf: single-level dome cars. |
| Food and Beverage Service | No cafe cars. Some trains have food carts with snacks and drinks. Many passengers purchase "ekiben" (boxed meals). | Both GoldLeaf and SilverLeaf include breakfast and lunch, plus complimentary snacks and beverages. GoldLeaf offers made-to-order meals in a dining car. SilverLeaf provides meals at your seat. Unlimited drinks, including alcoholic beverages, are available. |
| Punctuality and Reliability | Renowned for punctuality. Average delay is often less than one minute per year. | Some reviews mention potential delays and the possibility of transferring to buses. |
| Luggage Allowance and Handling | Two pieces of luggage allowed free of charge (max 250 cm total, length no more than 2 meters, weight no more than 30 kg). Luggage under 160cm can be brought on board without a reservation. For luggage between 160-250 cm, a prior reservation is required. | Each guest is allowed two pieces of checked luggage (total weight per person not exceeding 30 kg (66 lbs), with a maximum weight per piece of 23 kg (50 lbs)). Luggage is transported separately and delivered to your hotel. |
| Environmental Impact and Sustainability Initiatives | Not available | Committed to sustainability, focusing on protecting travel areas, using resources wisely, and supporting local communities. Aims to decrease environmental impact by decreasing waste and carbon emissions. |
Overall Comparison
Punctuality: Shinkansen wins; Scenery: Rocky Mountaineer wins; Food: Rocky Mountaineer wins
Pros and Cons
Japan Railway (Shinkansen)
Pros:
- Speed
- Punctuality
- Comfort
- Accessibility
- Efficiency
- Scenic views
Cons:
- No cafe cars
- Food and beverage options are limited to carts and ekiben
- Environmental Impact and Sustainability Initiatives information was not found
Rocky Mountaineer
Pros:
- Scenic views through glass-dome windows
- Comfortable seating with ample legroom
- High-quality food and beverage service
- Seamless luggage handling
- Accommodations for passengers with disabilities
- Onboard hosts providing commentary and assistance
Cons:
- Potential delays and bus transfers
- Wi-Fi reliability is not consistently mentioned
- Premium pricing
User Experiences and Feedback
Japan Railway (Shinkansen)
What Users Love
- Comfortable seating with ample legroom
- Exceptional punctuality
- Helpful staff
- Reliable Wi-Fi
- Scenic views
- Accessible for passengers with disabilities
- Efficient travel
Common Complaints
- No major complaints reported.
Value Perception
- Ticket prices depend on distance, class, and season
- Travel packages and regional passes can offer cost-effective options
User Recommendations
- The Shinkansen is highly recommended for its speed, punctuality, comfort, and accessibility, making it an efficient and enjoyable way to travel in Japan.
Rocky Mountaineer
What Users Love
- Very comfortable seating
- Ample legroom
- Fresh, local ingredients in food
- Knowledgeable and attentive onboard hosts
- Stunning vistas
- Unique and luxurious way to experience the scenery
Common Complaints
- Potential delays
- Possibility of transferring to buses
Value Perception
- Some reviewers suggest traveling during the shoulder season (May or September) to save money.
User Recommendations
- The scenic views are a highlight of the Rocky Mountaineer experience.
- Many reviews highly recommend the Rocky Mountaineer for its unique and luxurious way to experience the scenery of the Canadian Rockies and American Southwest.