Trenitalia Frecciarossa 1000 offers a higher top speed, broader route network, and a stronger focus on environmental sustainability. Brightline provides clear pricing and focuses on regional connectivity within Florida. The choice depends on the user's needs: for high-speed travel across major Italian cities with a focus on sustainability, Trenitalia is preferable. For regional travel within Florida with transparent pricing, Brightline is a better choice.
| Attribute | Brightline (Florida) | Trenitalia Frecciarossa 1000 |
|---|---|---|
| Top Speed (km/h) | 200 km/h (125 mph). Operates at varying speeds: up to 130 km/h (79 mph) between Miami and West Palm Beach, up to 180 km/h (110 mph) between West Palm Beach and Cocoa, and up to 200 km/h (125 mph) between Cocoa and Orlando. | Designed for 400 km/h, operates at 300 km/h (up to 393.8 km/h during testing) |
| Seating Capacity | Varies. Historically, four-car trainsets with 240 seats. Currently, primarily five-car trainsets with 306 seats. Working towards seven-car trains in mid-2025. Each Smart class car has 66 seats, while Premium cars have 50 seats. | 455-485 seats (including 2 wheelchair spaces) |
| Route Network Coverage | Connects Miami and Orlando, Florida. Stations in Miami, Aventura, Fort Lauderdale, Boca Raton, West Palm Beach, and Orlando. Future extension to Tampa is in planning. | Connects major Italian cities (Turin, Milan, Bologna, Florence, Rome, Naples, Salerno). Designed to operate on high-speed lines in France, Germany, Spain, Austria, Switzerland, Netherlands and Belgium. |
| Onboard Amenities (Wi-Fi, power outlets) | Free, high-speed Wi-Fi. Multiple power outlets and USB ports at each seat. | Wi-Fi (free with registration), power outlets at each seat, air conditioning, cafe car or bistro, on-board monitors with travel information and news |
| Ticket Pricing Structure | Two classes: Smart and Premium. One-way fares between Miami and Orlando start at $79 for SMART and $149 for PREMIUM. Average one-way ticket costs range from $30 to $99. | Four service levels: Executive, Business, Premium, and Standard. Prices vary depending on the class and booking time. |
| Frequency of Service | 32 trains daily between Orlando and Miami (16 departures from each city). Trains run approximately once or twice an hour from 7 a.m. to midnight (as of December 2023). | High frequency, up to 36 daily trains between Milan and Naples. 28 non-stop Frecciarossa trains between Milan and Rome each day. |
| Accessibility Features (wheelchair access) | ADA-compliant. Elevators, escalators, level boarding, wheelchair-accessible restrooms and seating. Wide aisles (32 inches) to accommodate wheelchairs and strollers. | Meets Passengers with Reduced Mobility (PRM) standards, designated spaces for wheelchairs and companions, wheelchair lifts for boarding, accessible restrooms |
| Luggage Storage Capacity | Overhead racks for carry-on luggage. Checked baggage service available. | Ample space in overhead bins and luggage compartments |
| Real-time Train Tracking | Available. | Real-time information available via the FRECCE Portal |
| Food and Beverage Options | Smart Class: Food and beverages available for purchase via QR code ordering. Premium Class: Complimentary snacks and beverages. Stations: Options like Mary Mary Bar and >>MRKT. | FrecciaBistrò offering meals, snacks, and drinks. At-seat service available in some classes. Welcome drinks and snacks in certain classes. |
| Comfort Level (seat pitch, legroom) | Leather seats in both classes. Premium class seats are wider (21 inches). Seats recline, but recline is limited. | Ergonomic seats designed for comfort. Four levels of service with varying seat features and legroom. Executive class offers extra-wide leather reclining seats and ample legroom. |
| Environmental Impact (emissions) | Diesel-electric engines run on clean biodiesel. Operations help remove CO2 emissions. | First high-speed train to receive Environmental Product Declaration (EPD). CO2 emissions limited to 28 grams per passenger-kilometer. Constructed with 85% recyclable and 95% renewable materials. |
| Price | One-way fares start at $79 for SMART service and $149 for PREMIUM service. Average one-way ticket costs range from $30 to $99. | Not available |
| Ratings | Reliability (Punctuality): Generally considered reliable and punctual. | Overall rating based on punctuality, comfort, and amenities is high. Performance is excellent due to advanced train control systems and safety measures. |