Both textbooks are well-regarded for their clarity and comprehensive coverage of their respective subjects. However, the presence of known errors in the Organic Chemistry textbook is a significant concern. Campbell Biology is a safer bet for a reliable and thorough introduction to biology, although its depth may be overwhelming for some students.
| Attribute | Campbell Biology (13th Edition) | Organic Chemistry (10th Edition) by Paula Yurkanis Bruice |
|---|---|---|
| Name | Campbell Biology (13th Edition) | — |
| Author(s) | Lisa A. Urry, Michael L. Cain, Steven A. Wasserman, Peter V. Minorsky, Jane B. Reece, Neil A. Campbell (founding author) | — |
| Publisher | Pearson | — |
| Publication Year | Potentially in development. 12th edition was published in 2020. | — |
| Page Count | Varies by edition. 11th edition: 1488 pages. 12th Australian and New Zealand version: 1552 pages. | — |
| Subject Matter | General Biology | — |
| Level | Introductory, College level. Suitable for majors, non-majors, and AP biology courses. | — |
| Availability of Digital Resources | MasteringBiology (online homework, tutorial, and assessment), Pearson eText (digital version of the textbook), interactive simulations, and online quizzes | — |
| Clarity of Explanations | Generally praised for clear and understandable explanations of complex concepts. Some find the depth overwhelming at times. | — |
| Quality of Illustrations and Diagrams | Diagrams are frequently described as excellent and highly useful for visual learners. | — |
| Inclusion of Practice Problems and Solutions | Includes chapter questions and problem-solving exercises. MasteringBiology offers tutorials and personalized feedback. | — |
| Relevance to Standard Curriculum | Aligns well with typical introductory biology courses. | — |
| Price | Not available | — |
| Ratings | Not available | — |
| Pros | Clear and understandable explanations of complex concepts, Excellent and highly useful illustrations and diagrams, Includes chapter questions and problem-solving exercises, Aligns well with typical introductory biology courses, Incorporates recent advances in fields like gene editing (CRISPR), genomics, microbiomes, and climate change impacts, Suitable for both self-study and classroom use, Provides a detailed overview of key concepts in biology | — |
| Cons | Depth of content can be overwhelming at times, Potential for differing opinions on certain topics | — |
| User Feedback - Negative | — |