Tea brands: DAVIDsTEA vs. Numi Organic Tea
Quick Verdict
Both DAVIDsTEA and Numi Organic Tea are excellent choices for tea lovers seeking high-quality, ethically sourced, and sustainable options. DAVIDsTEA stands out for its diverse flavor profiles and unique blends, while Numi excels in its commitment to organic and Fair Trade practices.
- Both brands offer a wide variety of teas and are committed to ethical sourcing and sustainability.
- DAVIDsTEA offers a wider range of flavors and exclusive blends, while Numi focuses on pure, organic ingredients.
- Numi has a stronger emphasis on Fair Trade certification and direct partnerships with growers.
Key features – Side-by-Side
| Attribute | DAVIDsTEA | Numi Organic Tea |
|---|---|---|
| Tea Variety | Wide variety, including black, green, herbal infusions, and matcha. Over 150 types, including exclusive blends and seasonal flavors. | Black, green, white, oolong, pu-erh, herbal teasans, and turmeric teas |
| Organic Certification | Growing collection certified organic by Ecocert Canada | USDA certified organic |
| Fair Trade Certification | Partners with Fair Trade USA | Many are Fair Trade Certified, or Verified Fair Labor program |
| Caffeine Level | Varying caffeine levels, from high to zero. Black teas: 10-100 mg, Green teas: 15-45 mg per 8 oz cup. Herbal, fruit, and rooibos infusions: no caffeine. | Low, medium, and high caffeine levels available. Generally, 15-70mg per 6-8 ounce cup |
| Ingredients Quality | Sustainable and ethically sourced ingredients from trusted partners. Robust supplier guidelines. | Premium organic tea leaves and herbs, blended with real fruits, flowers, and spices. No artificial or "natural" flavorings |
| Packaging Type | Loose leaf teas, prepackaged teas, and tea sachets. Sachets are plastic-free, plant-based, and biodegradable. | Bagged tea and loose leaf tea |
| Ethical Sourcing Practices | Committed to ethical sourcing, working with suppliers and members of the Ethical Tea Partnership (ETP). | Fair wages, safe working conditions, and community benefits for farmers. Direct partnerships with growers |
| Sustainability Initiatives | Transitioning to compostable and regenerative materials for packaging. Compostable shipping envelopes. | Carbon neutrality, compostable packaging, and support for clean water projects. Plant-based, compostable tea wrappers |
Overall Comparison
Variety: DAVIDsTEA wins; Organic: Numi wins; Ethical Sourcing: Numi and DAVIDsTEA are comparable; Sustainability: Numi and DAVIDsTEA are comparable
Pros and Cons
DAVIDsTEA
Pros:
- Wide selection of teas
- Unique blends
- Commitment to sustainability
- Offers a wide range of flavors and aromas to suit different preferences
- Transitioning to compostable packaging to maintain product quality and freshness
- Use 100% recyclable tea packaging and plastic-free sachets
- Ethical sourcing practices
Cons:
- Some reviewers consider the teas to be overpriced
Numi Organic Tea
Pros:
- Wide range of tea varieties
- USDA certified organic
- Fair Trade Certified or Verified Fair Labor program
- High-quality, organic ingredients
- Diverse flavor profiles
- Ethical sourcing practices
- Sustainable packaging and initiatives
- Availability online and in major grocery stores
Cons:
- May be more expensive due to sustainability efforts
User Experiences and Feedback
DAVIDsTEA
What Users Love
- Wide selection of teas
- Unique blends
- Commitment to sustainability
- Offers a wide range of flavors and aromas to suit different preferences
- Transitioning to compostable packaging to maintain product quality and freshness
- Use 100% recyclable tea packaging and plastic-free sachets
- Ethical sourcing practices
Common Complaints
- Some reviewers consider the teas to be overpriced
Value Perception
- No value feedback reported.
User Recommendations
- Nadia, DAVIDsTEA's Director of Tea Sustainability and Content, utilizes her scientific background to ensure product copy authentically represents the ingredients inside teas.
- Some reviewers find DAVIDsTEA to be a level up from ordinary, but not great, and consider the teas to be overpriced.
Numi Organic Tea
What Users Love
- Rich and inviting aroma
- Pure, premium ingredients
- Sustainable packaging
- Ethical sourcing
- Wide variety of teas with different flavor profiles and caffeine levels
- Tea bag wrappers lined with sugarcane-based Non-GMO PLA and metalized eucalyptus layers to ensure freshness
Common Complaints
- No major complaints reported.
Value Perception
- No value feedback reported.
User Recommendations
- Numi is committed to using only pure, premium ingredients and crafting tea blends that let nature speak for itself.
- Numi is a leader in sourcing organic and Fair Trade certified teas, investing in tea-growing communities.