Apple One Premier is a comprehensive bundle for Apple enthusiasts, offering a wide array of services. YouTube Premium is best for those who heavily use YouTube and its music platform, providing an ad-free experience with convenient features like background playback and offline downloads. The choice depends on the user's preference for Apple's ecosystem versus YouTube's content.
| Attribute | Apple One Premier | YouTube Premium |
|---|---|---|
| Subscription Cost (Monthly) | $37.95 | Individual: $13.99, Family: $22.99, Student: $7.99, Premium Lite: $7.99 |
| Subscription Cost (Annually) | No annual option | Individual: $139.99 |
| Included Services | Apple Music, Apple TV+, Apple Arcade, Apple News+, Apple Fitness+, iCloud+ (2TB) | Ad-free YouTube, YouTube Music, YouTube Kids, YouTube Music Premium |
| Ad-Free Access | Apple Arcade and Apple Music | YouTube, YouTube Music, YouTube Kids (creator branding may still appear) |
| Offline Content Availability | Apple Music (downloadable songs), Apple Arcade (playable games) | Downloadable videos/playlists, Smart Downloads (up to 30 days, 10 devices) |
| Family Sharing | Up to 6 users | Up to 5 family members (same household) |
| Content Quality | Apple TV+ (4K HDR), Apple Music (lossless audio, Spatial Audio) | Enhanced bitrate 1080p, High-quality audio (256 kbps) |
| Original Content Library | Apple TV+ (Apple Originals), Apple Music (exclusive content) | YouTube Originals (program ended January 2022) |
| Device Compatibility | iPhone, iPad, iPod touch, Mac, Apple TV, HomePod, Apple Watch, Android (Apple Music), select smart TVs | Devices with Google Account sign-in (smart TVs, gaming consoles, mobile apps) |
| Background Playback | Generally supported | Supported (can be turned off) |
| Exclusive Features | Apple News+ Food section (iOS 18.4/iPadOS 18.4), Invites app (iCloud+) | Picture-in-picture, Smart Downloads, Continue Watching, Queue videos |
| Free Trial | 1-month (for services not already subscribed to) | 1-month (eligible new members), extended trials via promotions |
| Cancellation Policy | Cancel 1 day before renewal, access until end of billing cycle | Cancel anytime, benefits continue until end of billing period |