Patrick Mahomes edges out Dak Prescott due to his superior statistics in key areas such as passing yards per game, touchdown to interception ratio, rushing yards, and Super Bowl wins. While both quarterbacks are considered leaders and clutch performers, Mahomes' overall performance and accolades give him the advantage.
| Attribute | Dak Prescott | Patrick Mahomes |
|---|---|---|
| Passing Yards per Game | 258.0 (Career), 259.8 (Since 2023) | 288.9 |
| Touchdown to Interception Ratio | Not available | 3.31 |
| Completion Percentage | 66.9% (Career) | 66.6 |
| Rushing Yards | Not available | 2,243 |
| Games Played | 122 | Enters his ninth season with the Chiefs in 2025 and his eighth year as the starter (2018-2025) |
| Playoff Appearances | 7 | Six times, headed for his seventh consecutive playoff run |
| Super Bowl Wins | None | Three |
| Quarterback Rating | 98.2 (Career), 105.9 (2023) | 102.1 |
| Average Passing Distance | 8.6 yards | Not available |
| Sack Rate | 6.8% | Not available |
| Leadership Qualities | Selfless and determined leader | Displays humility, flexibility, and acknowledges leadership as a privilege. He credits his team when they win and takes responsibility when they lose. He builds trust by developing a culture of honor, respect, vulnerability, and fun. |
| Clutch Performance | Considered the most 'clutch' signal-caller in the NFL | Known for staying calm under pressure and performing in big moments. |
| Injuries | History of injuries | History of major injuries including ankle sprains, knee patella dislocation, concussions, and turf toe |