Soft drinks: Pepsi vs. Mountain Dew
Quick Verdict
Both are popular carbonated beverages with distinct flavor profiles and varying levels of caffeine and sugar, catering to different preferences.
- Mountain Dew has a higher caffeine and sugar content than Pepsi.
- Pepsi is perceived as sweeter than Coke, while Mountain Dew has a citrus-forward flavor.
- Both offer diet versions, but Pepsi Zero Sugar has higher caffeine than regular Pepsi.
Key features – Side-by-Side
| Attribute | Pepsi | Mountain Dew |
|---|---|---|
| Flavor profile | Distinct flavor profile of caramel, vanilla, and cola nut extract. Often described as sweeter than Coke, with bright citrus notes. Some also describe it as having a lemony and fruity flavor. | Citrus-flavored, lemon-lime with a bolder lime punch, contains orange juice |
| Sweetness level | Sweeter than Coca-Cola. A 12oz serving contains 41g of sugar. | High sugar content, 46g per 12oz can |
| Caffeine content | Approximately 38 mg of caffeine in a 12-ounce can. | 54-55 mg per 12oz can |
| Carbonation level | Some perceive it as being less carbonated or 'flatter' compared to Coke. | Less carbonated compared to other sodas |
| Calorie count per serving | Around 150 calories in a 12 fl. oz (330ml) can. | 170 calories per 12oz can, 290 calories per 20oz bottle |
| Availability of sugar-free/diet versions | Diet Pepsi and Pepsi Zero Sugar (also known as Pepsi Max). Pepsi Zero Sugar has a significantly higher caffeine content compared to regular Pepsi. | Diet Mountain Dew and Mountain Dew Zero Sugar available |
| Acidity level (pH) | Around 2.39. This makes it an extremely erosive beverage that can potentially damage tooth enamel. | pH typically ranging from 3.2 to 3.7 |
Overall Comparison
Sugar: Mountain Dew higher; Caffeine: Mountain Dew higher; Flavor: Pepsi citrusy/caramel, Mountain Dew citrus/lime
Pros and Cons
Pepsi
Pros:
- Distinct citrusy flavor
- Variety of packaging options convenient for on-the-go consumption
- Contains caffeine for a temporary energy boost
- Offers diet versions (Diet Pepsi, Pepsi Zero Sugar)
Cons:
- Higher sugar content than some alternatives
- Some perceive it as less carbonated
- May have a metallic aftertaste for some people
- High acidity level can potentially damage tooth enamel
- Some Reddit users have noted that Pepsi can go flat relatively quickly.
Mountain Dew
Pros:
- Intense citrus flavor
- Provides a mild energy boost
- Budget-friendly option for a moderate energy boost
- Refreshing beverage
- Convenient on-the-go consumption with sleek bottle design
Cons:
- High sugar content
- May have a lingering, stale aftertaste
- High sugar content may not be the most effective thirst quencher
- Less carbonated than other sodas
User Experiences and Feedback
Pepsi
What Users Love
- Refreshing beverage option (depending on individual preference)
- Provides a temporary energy boost due to caffeine
Common Complaints
- Considered sweeter than Coke by many
- Some describe a metallic aftertaste
- High sugar content may not be ideal for everyone
- Can go flat relatively quickly according to some users
Value Perception
- Not available
User Recommendations
- Pepsi has a citrusy flavor compared to the vanilla-raisin flavor of Coke.
- Some people describe Pepsi as having a metallic aftertaste.
- Some Reddit users have noted that Pepsi can go flat relatively quickly.
Mountain Dew
What Users Love
- Refreshing
- Provides a mild energy boost
Common Complaints
- Overpowering sweetness
- Lingering, stale aftertaste
- Less carbonated than other sodas
Value Perception
- Budget-friendly option for a moderate energy boost
User Recommendations
- Many would recommend it as a refreshing beverage.
- Many find the sweetness overpowering.