Skincare brands: Drunk Elephant vs. Paula's Choice
Quick Verdict
Both Drunk Elephant and Paula's Choice offer effective skincare solutions with different focuses. Drunk Elephant emphasizes 'clean' ingredients and playful packaging, while Paula's Choice prioritizes research-backed formulations and targeted treatments. The best choice depends on individual preferences and skin concerns.
- Both brands are cruelty-free and offer fragrance-free options.
- Drunk Elephant emphasizes 'biocompatible' ingredients, while Paula's Choice focuses on research-backed ingredients.
- Paula's Choice offers a wider range of product lines targeting specific skin concerns.
- Both brands have mixed reviews regarding value for money.
Key features – Side-by-Side
| Attribute | Drunk Elephant | Paula's Choice |
|---|---|---|
| Ingredients Quality and Safety | Emphasizes biocompatible ingredients, avoiding 'Suspicious 6'. | Uses research-backed ingredients, avoids irritants like synthetic fragrances and essential oils. Not a 'clean' brand. |
| Effectiveness for Specific Skin Concerns | T.L.C. Framboos Glycolic Night Serum for acne; T.L.C. Sukari Babyfacial for smoothing; Protini Polypeptide Cream for fine lines; A-Passioni Retinol Cream for complexion. | CLEAR line for acne; 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant for acne and pore size; Retinol, peptides, and antioxidants for aging. |
| Suitability for Different Skin Types | B-Hydra Intensive Hydration Serum for oily, dry, and combination skin; Virgin Marula Luxury Face Oil for oily and normal to dry skin; Lala Retro Whipped Cream for normal to dry skin; Suitable for sensitive skin. | Balance and Clear lines for oily skin; AHA exfoliants, Skin Recovery Moisturizer for dry skin; CALM collection for sensitive skin; Clear Face Cleanser for combination skin. |
| Product Range and Variety | Offers cleansers, serums, moisturizers, eye treatments, and sunscreens. Offers starter kits like 'The Littles'. | Wide range for various skin types and concerns. Collections include Calm, Clear, Clinical, and Resist. |
| Price Point and Value for Money | Mid-range to high-end, $20 to over $100. Mixed reviews on value. | Some reviewers find it reasonably priced, while others note certain products can be expensive. |
| Packaging and Product Design | Colorful, simple, and playful with elephant illustrations. Airtight and suitable for travel. | Smart skincare packaging with airless pumps, opaque bottles, and UV-protected containers. Working towards sustainable packaging. |
| Brand Reputation and Ethical Practices | Cruelty-free, certified by PETA and Leaping Bunny. Focuses on ethically sourced ingredients. | Does not test on animals (Leaping Bunny Program). Committed to sustainably sourced ingredients and recyclable packaging. |
| Texture and Absorption of Products | Many products are lightweight and easily absorbed. B-Hydra Intensive Hydration Serum is known for its lightweight, non-greasy formula. | Many products have lightweight textures and quick absorption. |
| Scent | Generally fragrance-free. | Most products are fragrance-free. |
Overall Comparison
Ingredients: Differing philosophies; Price: Mixed reviews on value; Cruelty-free: Both brands
Pros and Cons
Drunk Elephant
Pros:
- Uses biocompatible ingredients
- Cruelty-free
- Wide range of products
- Lightweight texture and easy absorption for many products
- Generally fragrance-free
- Airtight and travel-friendly packaging
- Ethically sourced ingredients
Cons:
- Considered a mid-range to high-end brand
- Some reviewers feel the products are overpriced
- Some products can cause irritation for sensitive skin
Paula's Choice
Pros:
- Effective for various skin concerns
- Wide product range
- Smart skincare packaging
- Cruelty-free
- Many products are fragrance-free
- Lightweight textures and quick absorption
Cons:
- Some products can be expensive
- Some customers have reported issues with customer service and shipping
- Potential for irritation for sensitive skin
User Experiences and Feedback
Drunk Elephant
What Users Love
- Effective for hydration
- Effective for skin smoothing
- Improved skin tone and texture
- Lightweight and works well under makeup
- Improved skin hydration, texture, and overall health
- Smaller pores, less redness, and a more even skin tone
Common Complaints
- Questionable value for money
- Can cause irritation for sensitive skin
Value Perception
- Some reviewers find Drunk Elephant products more effective than others they've tried
- Some believe similar results can be achieved with less expensive alternatives
Paula's Choice
What Users Love
- Effective in calming acne and reducing pore size (2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant)
- Regular use can lead to smoother, brighter skin, reduced hyperpigmentation, and improved skin texture
- Some products wear well under makeup and can even act as a primer
Common Complaints
- Some users, especially those with sensitive skin, have reported irritation, redness, or breakouts
- Some customers have reported issues with customer service and shipping
Value Perception
- Some reviewers find Paula's Choice products more effective than other brands
- Some reviewers find the brand to be reasonably priced.