AI-Powered Universal Comparison Engine

Real estate platforms: RedfinNow iBuyer Service vs. Apartments.com Rental Manager

Quick Verdict

RedfinNow is suitable for sellers prioritizing speed and convenience over maximizing sale price, while Apartments.com Rental Manager is ideal for landlords seeking to streamline rental management for a small number of units.

Key features – Side-by-Side

AttributeRedfinNow iBuyer ServiceApartments.com Rental Manager
Service Area CoverageAvailable in 23 markets across nine states and the District of Columbia, including Boston, Inland Empire, Los Angeles, Orange County, Palm Springs, Phoenix, Sacramento, San Antonio, San Diego, San Francisco, Seattle and Tucson. In Seattle, it covered parts of King, Pierce, and Snohomish counties. In the Bay Area, it was available in the East Bay and South San Jose areas.Not available
Offer/Service SpeedProvided a 'top offer' within 24 hours of viewing the property. Sellers could get a cash offer within a few days of making a request.Streamlines the rental process with tools to list properties, screen tenants, create leases, and collect payments
Offer Accuracy vs. Market ValueOffers were typically 5-15% below market value.Offers rental comp reports to provide insights into property values
Closing Timeline FlexibilitySellers could pick their closing date, typically between 10 to 90 days after accepting the offer. A closing window of 14 60 days was also offered.Not available
Inspection RequirementsRequired a third-party home inspection, usually within 7 10 days of signing a contract. Additional inspections, such as roof inspections, were sometimes required.Not available
Repair Cost DeductionsRepair costs identified during the inspection were deducted from the offer. Sellers could either accept the reduced offer or cancel the sale without penalties if they disagreed with the repair estimates.Older rental properties usually require more repairs and maintenance than newer ones, which may result in higher fees
Service Fees/CommissionCharged service fees and closing costs that totaled 6 16% of the home's sale price. The service fee ranged from 5 13%. Closing costs typically amounted to 1 3% of the home's sale price.Apartments.com Rental Tools and its associated payments feature are free to use. Renters can pay with their checking account (ACH transfer) for free. However, renters will be charged a 2.75% fee if they choose to pay with a credit card, debit card, or Google Pay. Applicants pay $29.00 + tax for their application and tenant screening reports.
Property Eligibility Criteria (age, condition)Generally purchased homes valued between $150,000 and $1.5 million. Eligible properties were typically single-family homes or townhouses/condos. Homes generally needed to be built after 1960 (in some markets, after 1930 or 1900). The lot size had to be under half an acre (or one acre in some markets). The property needed to be owner-occupied or vacant and in good condition with a clear title. Ineligible properties included mobile homes, homes in age-restricted communities, those with unpermitted additions, and properties with major foundation issues.Suitable for managing 10 units or fewer but may not meet the needs of larger portfolios.
Financing Options (if any)RedfinNow was a cash buyer, so sellers didn't have to worry about financing contingencies.Not available
Rental Application Management FeaturesNot availableProvides a user-friendly platform for tenant screening, gathering necessary information, and finding qualified renters quickly. It partners with TransUnion to provide screening reports.
Tenant Screening ToolsNot availableOffers tenant screening tools, including credit, criminal, and eviction data
Rent Collection OptionsNot availableOffers online rent collection, allowing you to receive rent payments and security deposits safely and securely. Tenants can set up automatic rent payments. Express Pay allows you to receive ACH payments a day sooner

Overall Comparison

RedfinNow offers are typically 5-15% below market value with service fees of 6-16%, while Apartments.com Rental Manager is free to use, but charges renters a 2.75% fee for credit card payments and applicants $29.00 + tax for screening reports.

Pros and Cons

RedfinNow iBuyer Service

Pros:
  • Cash offer
  • Fast offer speed
  • Flexible closing timeline
  • Transparency of communication
Cons:
  • Offers typically 5-15% below market value
  • Service fees and closing costs totaling 6–16% of the home's sale price
  • Repair costs deducted from the offer
  • Strict property eligibility criteria
  • Limited availability

Apartments.com Rental Manager

Pros:
  • Helps landlords manage rental properties
  • Provides tools to fill vacancies, screen tenants, collect rent, and manage maintenance requests and expenses
  • Offers rental comp reports to provide insights into property values
  • Streamlines the rental process with tools to list properties, screen tenants, create leases, and collect payments
  • Provides a user-friendly platform for tenant screening
  • Offers tenant screening tools, including credit, criminal, and eviction data
  • Offers online rent collection
  • Renters can pay how they want, including with a credit card, bank transfer, Apple Pay, or Google Pay
  • Tenants can set up automatic rent payments
  • Express Pay allows you to receive ACH payments a day sooner
  • Applicant screening process is praised for its simplicity and efficiency in managing applications
Cons:
  • May not meet the needs of larger portfolios (suitable for managing 10 units or fewer)
  • Renters are charged a 2.75% fee if they choose to pay with a credit card, debit card, or Google Pay
  • Older rental properties usually require more repairs and maintenance than newer ones, which may result in higher fees

User Experiences and Feedback