AI-Powered Universal Comparison Engine

Pet training services: American Kennel Club Canine Good Citizen Program vs. Brain Training For Dogs

Quick Verdict

The American Kennel Club Canine Good Citizen program is ideal for owners seeking a recognized certification and structured obedience training in a real-world setting. Brain Training For Dogs is a better choice for owners looking for an affordable, online program to address specific behavioral issues and provide mental stimulation through games and puzzles.

Key features – Side-by-Side

AttributeAmerican Kennel Club Canine Good Citizen ProgramBrain Training For Dogs
NameAmerican Kennel Club Canine Good Citizen ProgramBrain Training For Dogs
Certification OfferedAKC Canine Good Citizen certificateThe program itself doesn't offer a formal certification. It is created by Adrienne Farricelli, a CPDT-KA certified dog trainer.
Trainer QualificationsAKC-approved CGC evaluatorCreated by Adrienne Farricelli, a CPDT-KA certified professional dog trainer with over 10 years of experience. She also holds certifications from the Italian Association for Dog Trainers and Canine Consultants.
Training MethodsBasic obedience commands (sit, stay, down, come, heel), positive reinforcement, real-world exposure in public spaces, controlled interactions with other dogs and peopleUses positive reinforcement techniques. Focuses on mental stimulation through games and puzzles. Avoids harsh methods or punishment.
Curriculum StructureTeaches 10 skills, covers responsible dog ownership, 8-week sample curriculum availableStructured like a school curriculum, progressing through levels: Preschool, Elementary, High School, College, University, Graduation, and Einstein. Each level includes step-by-step guides, pictures, and video demonstrations. Includes Obedience 101 training to teach basic commands.
PersonalizationSome programs account for a dog's unique personality and needsSuitable for all breeds and ages. Allows owners to address specific behavioral issues.
Support AvailabilityTraining resources provided by AKC, list of AKC Training Clubs availableIncludes a support system. Users can submit questions directly to Adrienne Farricelli. Provides access to a private forum for discussions.
AccessibilityOpen to all dogs regardless of age, breed, or prior training, classes offered at local AKC Training Clubs and some Petco locationsAn online program, accessible from anywhere with an internet connection. Training materials are available as ebooks and videos.
Time CommitmentTraining: 1-2 months, classes: 4-8 weeks, 1 hour per weekLessons are broken down into 10-15 minute sessions.
Equipment NeededCollar, leash, legally compliant identification tag, toys, treats, grooming brush, drying towelSome games may require readily available items like tennis balls or muffin tins. Substitutions are often provided.
Guaranteed ResultsDesigned to reward dogs who have good manners at home and in the communityOffers a 60-day money-back guarantee.
CostTest only: $20-$85, AKC title/certificate submission: $15-$25, varies depending on the training facility$47 to $67 (one-time payment, some sources mention a previous price of $97)
PriceNot available$47 to $67 (one-time payment, some sources mention a previous price of $97)
RatingsNot availableOverall positive based on user feedback.

Overall Comparison

AKC CGC: Test cost $20-$85, Brain Training For Dogs: $47-$67. AKC CGC: 1-2 months training, Brain Training For Dogs: 10-15 minute sessions. Brain Training For Dogs offers a 60-day money-back guarantee.

Pros and Cons

American Kennel Club Canine Good Citizen Program

Pros:
  • Recognized as the gold standard for dog behavior
  • CGC certification opens doors to various public spaces and activities
  • Encourages effective communication between owner and dog
  • Exposes dogs to various social situations, people, and other dogs
Cons:
  • Most dog training programs don't account for your dog's unique personality and needs

Brain Training For Dogs

Pros:
  • Effective in addressing behavioral issues
  • Affordable compared to private dog trainers
  • Comprehensive content and resources
  • Uses positive reinforcement methods
  • Clear instructions with pictures and video demonstrations
  • Includes troubleshooting segments
  • Offers access to a private forum and support system
  • Suitable for all breeds and ages
  • Allows owners to focus on specific behavioral issues
  • Online-based with instant access to materials
  • Structured with progressive levels and includes 'exam' videos
  • 60-day money-back guarantee
Cons:
  • Requires internet access
  • Some games may require specific equipment (though substitutions are provided)
  • Core program focuses on individual training, socialization requires adaptation

User Experiences and Feedback