Pet supply retailers > The Farmer's Dog vs. Chewy
Selecting the right pet food service is crucial for your pet's health and well-being. This comparison highlights the key differences between The Farmer's Dog, known for its fresh, customized meals, and Chewy, a comprehensive online pet store with a vast selection of food options.
This comparison analyzes real-world performance, user feedback, and key differentiators to help you make an informed decision.
Quick Verdict
For pet owners prioritizing fresh, human-grade, customized meals and willing to pay a premium, The Farmer's Dog is the better choice. For those seeking a wide variety of brands, budget-friendly options, and the convenience of a comprehensive pet supply retailer, Chewy is the preferred option.
- The Farmer's Dog provides highly customized, human-grade meals, while Chewy offers a broad selection of pet food brands and types.
- Chewy's Autoship program offers cost savings and convenience, but The Farmer's Dog focuses on pre-portioned, fresh meals.
- Both companies provide excellent customer service and flexible subscription options.
Who Should Choose Which?
Choose The Farmer's Dog if:
Pet owners who prioritize human-grade ingredients, customized meal plans, and are willing to invest in premium pet food.
Choose Chewy if:
Pet owners who value a wide selection of brands, budget-friendly options, and the convenience of a one-stop-shop for all pet supplies.
Key features – Side-by-Side
| Attribute | The Farmer's Dog | Chewy |
|---|---|---|
| Food Quality | Human-grade ingredients, recipes formulated by veterinary nutritionists, complete and balanced according to AAFCO standards. | Offers a wide range, including options with human-grade ingredients and brands with common allergens like corn, wheat, and soy. |
| Customization Options | Customized meal plans based on breed, age, weight, activity level, and allergies. | Provides foods for different animals and dietary needs, including grain-free and limited ingredient options. |
| Subscription Flexibility | Easy to pause, cancel, or reschedule online. | Autoship program allows adjusting delivery frequency, skipping orders, or canceling at any time. |
| Price per Serving/Meal | Approximately $17 to $150 per week, varying by dog's size and needs. | Starting price less than $2 per meal, with Autoship discounts available. |
| Customer Service | Offers 24/7 customer service via phone or email. | Known for excellent customer service, offering 24/7 support via phone, live chat, or email. |
| Return & Refund Policy | 100% satisfaction guarantee, alternative recipes or refund if the dog doesn't like the food. | Full refund or replacement within 365 days if not satisfied, often encourages donation to a shelter. |
Overall Comparison
Pros and Cons
The Farmer's Dog
- Human-grade ingredients
- Customized meal plans
- Flexible subscription
- Eco-friendly packaging
- Responsive customer service
- Pre-portioned meals
- Transparent nutritional information
- Satisfaction guarantee
- No major disadvantages reported.
Chewy
- Wide range of pet food options
- Customizable for different dietary needs and animals
- Flexible Autoship program
- Excellent customer service
- Generous return policy
- Some brands contain common allergens
- Information on portion control and nutritional transparency not available
User Experiences and Feedback
The Farmer's Dog
- High-quality proteins and vegetables
- Caters to dietary restrictions and allergies
- Easy to adjust subscription
- Fresh food upon arrival
- Eco-friendly packaging
- Responsive and helpful customer service
- Variety of recipes and protein sources
- Pre-packaged and easy to serve
- Transparent guaranteed analysis
- Good return policy
- No major complaints reported.
- Cost varies depending on the dog's size, age, breed, activity level, and specific food ingredients. It can range from $2 to $21.42 per day.
Chewy
- No highlights reported.
- No major complaints reported.
- No value feedback reported.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which service is more affordable?
Chewy generally offers more affordable options due to its wide range of brands and price points, while The Farmer's Dog is a premium service with higher costs.
Which service offers more variety?
Chewy offers a vast variety of brands, food types, and recipes, while The Farmer's Dog focuses on a limited selection of fresh, human-grade recipes.
Sources & Citations
- Official product specifications
- Expert reviews from tech publications
- User feedback from online forums
Information gathered through AI-assisted web search and analysis. Last updated: August 2025
Methodology & Transparency
Our comparison methodology combines multiple data sources to provide comprehensive, unbiased analysis:
- Data Collection: We gather information from official specifications, user reviews, and independent testing
- AI-Assisted Analysis: Advanced AI helps process large amounts of data while maintaining accuracy
- Human Oversight: All comparisons are reviewed for accuracy and relevance
- Regular Updates: Content is refreshed to reflect new information and user feedback
- Bias Mitigation: We strive for objectivity by considering multiple perspectives and sources
Versusly.ai uses AI-assisted content generation combined with human oversight to deliver comprehensive comparisons. We are transparent about our process and continuously work to improve accuracy and usefulness.