Both The Farmer's Dog and Ollie are excellent choices for fresh, human-grade dog food with customizable meal plans and flexible subscriptions. The best choice depends on individual needs and priorities. The Farmer's Dog stands out for its commitment to eco-friendly packaging and guaranteed delivery times, while Ollie offers a broader range of recipes and more customer support options. Price sensitivity and dog size should also be considered when making a decision.
| Attribute | The Farmer's Dog | Ollie |
|---|---|---|
| Ingredient Quality | Human-grade ingredients from reputable food suppliers, local farms, and human food purveyors meeting USDA standards. All-natural and antibiotic-free meats without added hormones. Clean proteins, whole foods, and added vitamins and minerals. | High-quality, human-grade ingredients. No fillers, artificial flavors, animal by-products, or preservatives. Chicken and beef sourced from the US, lamb from the US, New Zealand, and Australia. Includes superfoods like kale, blueberries, and salmon oil. |
| Customization Options | Personalized meal plans tailored to a dog's specific needs, considering factors like age, weight, breed, activity level, and health concerns. | Personalized meal plans based on dog's age, weight, breed, activity level, and allergies. Customizable at any time. Offers health screenings. |
| Subscription Flexibility | Flexible subscriptions allowing modification of delivery schedules, skipping shipments, pausing, or canceling anytime without fees, as long as the order hasn't been processed. | Flexible subscription plans with adjustable delivery frequency and meal portions. Ability to delay orders, adjust meal plans, skip deliveries, or reschedule. |
| Price per Serving | Varies depending on the dog's size, age, and activity level, generally starting at around $2 per day. For a 50-pound adult dog, the price ranges from $7.25 to $8.00 per day, depending on the protein source. | Starts at less than $4 per day for small dogs exclusively fed Ollie, averaging $8 per day. Meal plans designed for twice-daily feeding at $2 per day or $1 per meal, but only if Ollie is the exclusive food source. Can range up to $12 per day for large dogs. |
| Shipping and Delivery | Fast and convenient deliveries with free shipping within the continental United States. Orders placed before 11 am Tuesday to Thursday are dispatched for next-day delivery. Meals are shipped in environmentally-friendly refrigerated cartons to maintain freshness. | Orders processed within 1-5 business days. Delivery times are estimates and not guaranteed. Shipping is free. |
| Packaging Sustainability | Eco-friendly packaging. Recyclable cardboard boxes, biodegradable insulation (compostable or dissolvable), and BPA-free and non-toxic food packs. | Recyclable packaging for shipping, including recyclable boxes and insulating liners. Food packages themselves aren't recyclable due to the easy-peel seal. |
| Veterinarian Approval | Recipes are formulated by board-certified veterinary nutritionists to meet AAFCO standards. | Recipes formulated by veterinary nutritionists and meet the minimum AAFCO nutrition standards. |
| Customer Support Quality | Responsive and helpful customer service available via email (help@thefarmersdog.com) or phone ((646) 780-7957). | Responsive and helpful via email, phone, and live chat. Can answer questions, address concerns, and adjust meal plans. |
| Recipe Variety | Four recipes: turkey, beef, chicken, and pork. | Offers beef, chicken, turkey, and lamb recipes. Also offers fresh and baked food choices. |
| Portion Control | Meals are pre-portioned based on your dog's calorie needs, considering breed, age, activity level, and ideal weight. | Meal plans specify portion sizes and feeding frequency, promoting healthy weight management. Portions are customized by weight groupings. |
| Dietary Needs Support (e.g., allergies) | Customizable meals to suit dietary needs, including common allergies or sensitivities. Recipes are free of wheat and corn. | Tailors meal plans to avoid triggering ingredients if your dog has allergies. Offers single-protein recipes and grain-free options. |
| Transition Support | Guidance and support to help transition your pet to a fresh food diet, recommending a gradual transition. | Provides guidance and support to help transition your pet to a fresh food diet. Starter packs include information on portioning and transitioning your pup. |