Ollie stands out for its human-grade ingredients, personalized meal plans, and fresh food delivery service, making it a premium option. Nutro offers a wider range of recipes for different life stages and dietary needs, but its ingredient quality and the presence of 'natural flavors' may be a concern for some pet owners. The choice depends on individual priorities, with Ollie prioritizing ingredient quality and customization, and Nutro focusing on variety and accessibility.
| Attribute | Ollie | Nutro |
|---|---|---|
| Ingredient Quality | Human-grade ingredients from trusted vendors, made in USDA-certified kitchens. | Emphasizes sustainability, ingredient quality, and nutritional value. Aims to use healthy soil practices and is transparent about ingredient benefits. Some recipes contain potentially controversial ingredients like unspecified fish oil, dried tomato pomace, and "natural flavor". Partners with trusted farmers and suppliers to source high-quality ingredients. |
| Protein Source and Content | Beef, chicken, turkey, lamb, and pork. Real meat is the first ingredient. Protein content ranges from 35% to 44% on a dry matter basis. | Recipes typically list a named quality meat source as the top ingredient. Common protein sources include chicken, lamb, salmon, turkey, fish, and venison meal. Protein content varies depending on the product line. Nutro Ultra Superfood Plate with a Trio of Proteins has 26.6% protein (as dry matter). Nutro Natural Choice Small Breed Adult Chicken and Brown Rice has 27.7% protein. |
| Carbohydrate Source and Content | Sweet potatoes, oats, lentils, rice, and chickpeas. Estimated carbohydrate content is 35.5%. | Uses grains like brown rice, brewers rice, barley, and sorghum as carbohydrate sources. Some grain-free options are available. Carbohydrate content varies; Nutro Natural Choice Small Breed Adult Chicken and Brown Rice has roughly 42.1% carbohydrates. |
| Fat Source and Content | Salmon oil, coconut oil, and cod liver oil. Mean fat level is 22.7%. | Fat sources include chicken fat, sunflower oil, canola oil, and fish oil. Fat content varies; Nutro Ultra Superfood Plate has 16.6% fat (as dry matter). |
| Fiber Content and Source | Squash, oats, lentils, spinach, blueberries, kale, sweet potatoes, and pumpkin. Fiber content is around 2%. | Fiber sources include brown rice, dried plain beet pulp, lentils, flaxseed, and tomato pomace. |
| Vitamin and Mineral Content | Includes a variety of vitamins and minerals, with specific ingredients like spinach, blueberries, and kale contributing to the nutrient profile. They also use chelated minerals. | Includes various vitamins and minerals to support overall health. Examples include Vitamin E, selenium, zinc oxide, and Vitamin B12. |
| Presence of Artificial Additives | Does not include artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives. Rosemary is used as a natural preservative. | Dry dog food contains no artificial preservatives or flavors. Some recipes may contain "natural flavors," which can be controversial. |
| Specific Dietary Needs Support | Offers both grain-inclusive and grain-free options. Allows exclusion of specific allergens. Some recipes, like the Chicken Dish With Carrots, are suitable for dogs with sensitive stomachs. | Offers options for specific needs, including grain-free and limited ingredient diets for sensitivities. Also has weight management formulas. Nutro Natural Choice Sensitive Skin & Stomach formula is designed for dogs with sensitivities. |
| Life Stage Suitability | Meets the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for All Life Stages, making them suitable for puppies and adult dogs. | Provides recipes for all life stages, including puppy, adult, and senior. Offers specific formulas for different breed sizes. |
| Calorie Content and Portion Sizes | Calorie content varies depending on the recipe. Portion sizes are personalized based on dog's age, weight, breed, activity level, and body composition. | Calorie content and portion sizes vary depending on the recipe. Nutro Natural Choice Adult Chicken & Brown Rice has 341 kcal per cup. |
| Subscription Service Availability and Customization | Subscription-based service that delivers fresh food. Offers personalized meal plans. Customizable meal plans and delivery frequency. | Not available |
| Price per Serving | Ranges from approximately $3 per meal to $200 for a month's worth of food for medium dogs. Small dogs exclusively fed Ollie may cost less than $4 per day, while the average is around $8 per day. | Not available |