Nutro and Nom Nom both offer quality dog food, but they cater to different priorities and budgets. Nutro provides a wider range of options, including grain-inclusive and grain-free, and is generally more affordable. Nom Nom focuses on human-grade ingredients and customized meals, making it a premium choice. The best option depends on individual needs and preferences.
| Attribute | Nutro | Nom Nom |
|---|---|---|
| Protein Source | Chicken, lamb, salmon, turkey, fish, duck, and venison | Named meats like beef, chicken, turkey, and pork |
| Life Stage Suitability | Puppies, adults, and senior dogs; options for different breed sizes | All life stages (puppies, adults, seniors) |
| Grain Inclusion | Grain-inclusive (brown rice) and grain-free options available | Most recipes are grain-free; Turkey Fare contains brown rice, Lamb Pilaf contains rice |
| Ingredient Quality | High-quality, natural ingredients; avoids artificial additives, corn, wheat, and soy in many formulas; some recipes contain non-GMO ingredients. Some reviewers note processed ingredients and potential pesticide residue | Human-grade ingredients, gently cooked and minimally processed |
| Digestibility | Some report good digestibility, solid stools, and shiny coats; transition slowly to avoid gastrointestinal upset | Highly digestible, leading to better stool quality and reduced gas |
| Price per Pound | Premium | Varies depending on dog's size and needs; trial order around $254.85 for 2 weeks for a medium-sized dog; $86-$595 per month |
| Veterinarian Recommendation | Some vets recommend Nutro; others prefer Purina Pro Plan, Iams, Royal Canin, and Hills Science Diet | Recipes formulated by veterinary nutritionists; some vets note positive health outcomes |
| Recall History | Recalls issued in the past due to potential mold, plastic contamination, melamine contamination, and incorrect levels of zinc and potassium. No recalls since 2015 | No recalls for dog food; cat food recall in 2021 |
| Manufacturing Location | Dry food: Henderson, North Carolina, and Victorville, California. Wet food: Columbus, Ohio; Fort Smith, Arkansas; and North Sioux City, South Dakota. Some products made in Thailand | Nashville, Tennessee in their own kitchen facilities |
| Package Size Options | Variety of package sizes | Pre-portioned meals based on individual needs |
| Customer Support Availability | Headquarters in Franklin, Tennessee; 100% satisfaction guarantee; contact via phone or website | Email or phone (415-991-0669) |
| Special Dietary Options | Limited ingredient diets for allergies/sensitivities; options for weight management | Single-protein recipes available for dogs with allergies or sensitivities |