AI-Powered Universal Comparison Engine

Outdoor recreation equipment: Black Diamond Spot 400 Headlamp vs. Thule Approach Rooftop Tent

Quick Verdict

The Black Diamond Spot 400 Headlamp is a personal lighting solution, offering brightness and convenience in a compact design. The Thule Approach Rooftop Tent provides a comfortable and easily deployable shelter for camping, trading portability for space and convenience.

Key features – Side-by-Side

AttributeBlack Diamond Spot 400 HeadlampThule Approach Rooftop Tent
NameBlack Diamond Spot 400 HeadlampThule Approach Rooftop Tent
Brightness (Lumens)400 lmNot available
WeightWith AAA batteries: 77 g (2.7 oz), 86 g; With BD1500 battery: 72 g; Without batteries: 44.5 gApproach M: 128 lbs. Approach L: 150 lbs.
Battery Life (hours)High: 2.5 hours (AAA), 4 hours (BD 1500); Medium: 5 hours (AAA), 8 hours (BD 1500); Low: 200 hours (AAA), 225 hours (BD 1500)Not available
Beam Distance (meters)High: 100 m; Medium: 60 m; Low: 12 mNot available
Water Resistance Rating (IPX rating)IPX8 (tested to operate at least 1.1 meters underwater for 30 minutes). Some sources say IP67 for the 400-R model.Not available
Number of SleepersNot availableApproach M: 2-3 people (best with a maximum of three). Approach L: 3-4 people (best with a maximum of three).
Tent Dimensions (LxWxH)Not availableApproach M: Open: 95 x 56 x 40 inches, Closed: 49 x 56 x 11 inches. Approach L: Open: 96 x 72 x 40 inches, Closed: 49 x 72 x 11 inches.
Packed Size (LxWxH)Not availableApproach M: 49 x 56 x 11 inches. Approach L: 49 x 72 x 11 inches.
Setup TimeNot availableUnder 3 minutes (may take around 5 minutes for the first attempt).
Material Durability (denier)Not availableCanopy: Breathable, water-resistant 600D polyester ripstop. Rainfly: Thermoplastic-coated nylon. Base: Welded aluminum tube with insulation and an aluminum cap sheet.
Headlamp Light ModesProximity/flood, distance/spot, dimming, strobe, red LED night vision, and lock modeNot available
Rooftop Tent Mounting CompatibilityNot availableThule Wingbar, ProBar, SquareBar, Aerobar, and Xsporter Pro. Thule TracRac - Truck and Van (requires Thule Adapter Kit Xadapt 14).
PriceNot availableNot available
RatingsNot availableOverall: Not available, Performance: Handles wind and weather very well.
ProsLightweight and comfortable for extended use, Balanced weight distribution, Soft strap, Slim profile, Ergonomic design, Easily adjustable strap (even with lightweight gloves), IPX8 waterproof rating, Brightness Memory, PowerTap technologyEasy to mount with innovative mounting brackets, Lockable mounting brackets for added security, Panoramic skylights and windows for stargazing and ventilation, Includes internal pockets for storage, Durable materials including 600D polyester ripstop canopy.
ConsTwo-button design may require some learning, Adjusting strap may be more difficult with bulky winter glovesOccupancy number may be high by one (best with a maximum of three people for both M and L), Condensation can build up.

Overall Comparison

Black Diamond Spot 400 Headlamp: 400 lumens, IPX8 waterproof. Thule Approach Rooftop Tent: Sets up in under 3 minutes, sleeps 2-4 people.

Pros and Cons

Black Diamond Spot 400 Headlamp

Pros:
  • Lightweight and comfortable for extended use
  • Balanced weight distribution
  • Soft strap
  • Slim profile
  • Ergonomic design
  • Easily adjustable strap (even with lightweight gloves)
  • IPX8 waterproof rating
  • Brightness Memory
  • PowerTap technology
Cons:
  • Two-button design may require some learning
  • Adjusting strap may be more difficult with bulky winter gloves

Thule Approach Rooftop Tent

Pros:
  • Easy to mount with innovative mounting brackets.
  • Lockable mounting brackets for added security.
  • Panoramic skylights and windows for stargazing and ventilation.
  • Includes internal pockets for storage.
  • Durable materials including 600D polyester ripstop canopy.
Cons:
  • Occupancy number may be high by one (best with a maximum of three people for both M and L).
  • Condensation can build up.

User Experiences and Feedback