Both NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital and Mayo Clinic are highly reputable medical institutions offering a wide array of services and advanced technologies. Mayo Clinic consistently ranks as the top hospital in the US, but NewYork-Presbyterian also holds a strong position, particularly in the New York region. The choice between the two may depend on location, specific medical needs, and personal preferences.
| Attribute | NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital | Mayo Clinic |
|---|---|---|
| Hospital Reputation and Ranking | Ranked among the top hospitals in the US by U.S. News & World Report; #1 hospital in New York for over 20 consecutive years; Ranked #7 in the nation in 2022 and 2021; Evaluated based on clinical outcomes, level of nursing care, and patient experience. | #1 hospital in the U.S. by U.S. News & World Report for multiple years; #1 in Newsweek's 'World's Best Hospitals' in 2025 |
| Specialty Centers of Excellence | Top five nationally in cardiology and heart surgery, neurology/neurosurgery, psychiatry, diabetes/endocrinology, and rheumatology; Centers of Excellence for pancreatitis and pancreatic cancer care; Centers of Excellence for cardiac care, neurosurgery, and women's and children's health services. | Top-ranked in Diabetes & Endocrinology, Gastroenterology (GI) & GI Surgery, Pulmonology & Lung Surgery, Orthopedics, Neurology & Neurosurgery, Cancer, Cardiology, Heart & Vascular Surgery, Obstetrics & Gynecology |
| Advanced Technology and Equipment | Utilizes advanced technology, including machine learning; Implemented eICU system for remote patient monitoring; Uses robots for logistics and room service delivery; David H. Koch Center incorporates smart technology for a seamless patient experience. | Advanced imaging technologies (MRI, CT, PET scans), AI, 3D printing, Division of Engineering for medical devices, Biomedical Imaging Resource Core |
| Patient Satisfaction Scores | Consistently received high ratings for patient satisfaction; 90% of patients would definitely recommend the hospital; Overall rating of 89 out of 100; High employee satisfaction. | Five-star ratings for patient experience from CMS; above national averages; likelihood of recommending increased from 82.9% to 87.5% (2017-2021) |
| Range of Medical Services Offered | Cancer care, digestive diseases, heart care, neurology & neurosurgery, organ transplantation, orthopedics, pediatrics, psychiatry & behavioral health, rehabilitation medicine, vascular medicine, and women's health; Comprehensive care for women's health; Specialized services such as cardiac catheterization, cardiac surgery, and transplant services. | Primary and specialty care (cardiology, neurology, oncology, orthopedic surgery, gastroenterology); surgical services (general, minimally invasive, robotic, transplant); support services (physical therapy, mental health) |
| Research and Innovation Programs | Hub for medical innovation with over 2,000 clinical trials underway; Strong focus on medical research and education; Hauser Institute for Health Innovation to expand telehealth services. | Integrates clinical practice, education, and research; Mayo Clinic Research Innovation; Mayo Clinic Center for Innovation (CFI); Mayo Clinic Ventures |
| Physician Expertise and Credentials | More than 6,500 affiliated physicians; Affiliated with Columbia University Vagelos College of Physicians and Surgeons and Weill Cornell Medicine of Cornell University; All physicians at NewYork-Presbyterian Allen Hospital are on the faculty of Columbia University Vagelos College of Physicians and Surgeons. | Large number of physicians and scientists known for expertise and compassionate care |
| Accessibility and Location Convenience | Multiple campuses throughout the New York metropolitan area; Over 450 locations in NYC and Westchester; Offers digital health services. | Campuses in Rochester, MN; Jacksonville, FL; Phoenix/Scottsdale, AZ; network in Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Iowa |
| Insurance Coverage and Billing Transparency | Provides information on standard charges; Accepts most insurance plans, including Aetna, Blue Cross Blue Shield, Cigna, and UnitedHealthcare; Committed to providing accurate information about charges and payment options. | Cost Estimator tool available |
| Emergency Care Services and Trauma Level | Top centers for emergency care; Designated as 911 Ambulance-Receiving Centers; Level I Adult Trauma Services; Level I Pediatric Trauma Services; Verified Level I trauma center. | 24/7 emergency care; Level I Trauma Center (Saint Marys Campus); Level III (La Crosse), Level II (Eau Claire) |
| Support Services and Amenities | Patient transfers, surgical intensive care units, and burn care; Resources for patients and visitors; Pain management and psychosocial support. | Physical therapy and mental health services |
| Telehealth and Virtual Care Options | NYP OnDemand, including Digital Urgent Care and Virtual Visit; Virtual Urgent Care provides real-time telehealth access; Digital second opinions and digital consults. | Virtual care options, Primary Care On Demand app, Express Care Online |
| Price | Not available | Not available |
| Ratings | Overall rating of 89 out of 100 | Overall quality of care: High satisfaction scores |