ADT Self Setup is the better option due to its current availability, no-contract professional monitoring, and comprehensive features. Google Nest Secure (Upgraded Version) is no longer supported, making it an unviable option despite its past features.
| Attribute | ADT Self Setup | Google Nest Secure (Upgraded Version) |
|---|---|---|
| Name | ADT Self Setup | Google Nest Secure (Upgraded Version) |
| Professional monitoring option | Yes, offers 24/7 professional monitoring. | Available through Brinks Home Security, starting at $29.99 per month with a contract; included 24/7 monitoring with cellular backup for $19/month with a three-year contract or $29/month without a contract. |
| Self-monitoring option | No self-monitoring option available at the time of publishing. | Offered; users receive notifications, control devices remotely, and livestream footage via the Nest app. |
| Equipment cost | At least $269 to start (base station and a door/window sensor). Premade packages range from $349 to $1,573 (MSRP), but discounts are often available. | $399 |
| Monthly monitoring cost | Secure Monitoring (no video): $24.99/month. Complete Monitoring (with video): $39.99/month. Additional $7/month for 10 days of continuous video recording and 60-day event-based video history for Nest cameras. | $19 per month with a three-year contract, $29 per month month-to-month. |
| Contract length | No long-term contract required. | Monthly or three-year basis for professional monitoring; Brinks requires a contract. |
| Mobile app features | ADT+ app allows arming/disarming, live video streaming, sensor checks, smart home integration management, real-time updates, and device history. | Arming/disarming the system remotely, reviewing cloud storage, receiving notifications, livestreaming footage, two-way audio, controlling connected devices via Nest app; control and manage compatible devices via Google Home app. |
| Smart home integration | Integrates with Google Nest devices. Voice control via Google Nest smart speakers and displays. Broad third-party support via Z-Wave technology. | Alexa, Google Assistant, LIFX, Hue, other Nest products, ADT systems. |
| Ease of installation | Designed for easy DIY installation. Sensors come with peel-and-stick adhesive. | DIY system, professional installation available for $99.99 per device. |
| Battery backup duration | 24-hour battery backup. | Included with professional monitoring; keeps Nest devices on during power outages. |
| Cellular backup | Included in the Secure Monitoring plan ($24.99/month). | Included with professional monitoring; discontinued as of April 8, 2024. |
| Warranty period | Six-month money-back guarantee for system issues ADT can't resolve. | Limited warranty, typically one year for Nest Thermostat E or two years for other products; covers defects in materials and workmanship. |
| Types of sensors offered | Door/window sensors, motion sensors, smoke detectors, carbon monoxide sensors, flood & temperature sensors. | Nest Detect sensors for doors, windows, and motion detection; install between 5 and 6'4" above the floor. |
| Discontinuation | Not available | Discontinued in 2020, support ended April 8, 2024. |
| Replacement Options | Not available | Free ADT Self Setup security system or a credit to use on the Google Store offered to existing users. |
| Price | Expect to spend at least $269 to start | Not available |