Planet Fitness is best for individuals seeking an affordable and accessible gym with a welcoming environment, while CrossFit is better suited for those looking for a challenging, community-driven workout experience with personalized coaching, but at a higher cost.
| Attribute | Planet Fitness | CrossFit |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly membership cost | Classic membership starts at $15 a month, PF Black Card membership starts at $24.99 a month, annual fee of $49. The $15 Classic membership gives you access to your home club. The Black Card membership allows you to bring a guest, access to any Planet Fitness worldwide, and access to amenities like tanning and massage chairs. | Varies widely; Month-to-month: $180-$215; Unlimited access: $229-$259; Limited membership (12 classes/month): $219; With 2 private sessions: $260; Unlimited 12-month membership: $1680 upfront (averaging $140/month). |
| Equipment variety (cardio, strength, free weights) | Cardio: Treadmills, ellipticals, rowing machines, upright bikes, stepmills, recumbent steppers and bikes, arcs, and upper body ergometers. Strength: User-friendly machines to target different muscle groups, cable towers, Fitbench, mobility and stretching room, limited free weights (dumbbells and barbells), Smith machines and a 30-minute circuit. Some locations have functional stations with battle ropes, kettlebells, and medicine balls. Free Weights: Limited free weights. | Barbells, plates, pull-up bars, jump ropes, kettlebells, medicine balls. Some gyms also have dumbbells, plyo boxes, gymnastics rings, rowing machines, air bikes, ski ergs, and GHD machines. |
| Class offerings (yoga, Zumba, spin) | Free fitness training led by certified trainers through the PE@PF program. These include small group fitness classes and customized workout plans. The PF app also provides workout routines. | Besides CrossFit, some gyms offer yoga, boot camp, and specialized training. |
| Cleanliness of facilities (equipment, restrooms, showers) | Generally considered clean and well-maintained. | Cleanliness is essential. Gyms should have daily and deep cleaning schedules, use hospital-grade disinfectants, focus on high-touch points, and ensure proper ventilation. Regular cleaning of equipment and floors is a must. |
| Staff friendliness and helpfulness | Many reviews indicate that the staff is friendly and helpful. | Many reviews mention friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable coaches who focus on proper technique and offer modifications. |
| Gym atmosphere and community | Welcoming and non-intimidating, creating a "Judgement Free Zone". | Known for its strong community. It's a supportive and motivating environment where members encourage each other. |
| Availability of personal training services | Free fitness training in small groups with certified trainers. One-on-one personal training is generally not available. | Many CrossFit gyms offer personal training. This can provide customized workout plans, expert guidance, and motivation to help individuals meet their goals. |
| Operating hours | Many locations are open 24/7. Some locations may have varying hours, especially on weekends. | CrossFit gyms often have extensive schedules. |
| Location and accessibility | Over 2,700 locations worldwide, generally accessible. | CrossFit Incite in Mesa, AZ, is easily accessible from all of Mesa. |
| Contract flexibility (month-to-month, annual) | Both month-to-month and annual contracts. Canceling before the commitment period may involve a fee. | Some CrossFit gyms offer month-to-month memberships with flexible cancellation policies. |
| Crowd levels during peak hours | Can get crowded during peak hours, making it harder to access equipment. | Not available |
| Childcare availability | Does not offer childcare services. | Some CrossFit gyms offer childcare services during certain class times. This is often included in the membership. |