Peloton is best for individuals seeking a premium, immersive at-home fitness experience with a strong community and advanced digital integration, despite the higher cost. Planet Fitness is more suitable for those looking for an affordable, accessible gym with a welcoming atmosphere, even if it means sacrificing equipment variety and personalized training.
| Attribute | Peloton | Planet Fitness |
|---|---|---|
| Membership Cost | All-Access Membership: $44 per month; App One Membership: $12.99 per month; App+ Membership: $24 per month; Peloton Guide Membership (Guide-only): $24/month; Student App Membership: $6.99/month | Classic membership starts at $15 a month, PF Black Card membership starts at $24.99 a month. Annual fee of around $49. Some locations may have a one-time enrollment fee of $30-$100. |
| Equipment Variety | Offers indoor bikes (Bike, Bike+), treadmills (Tread, Tread+), and the Peloton Guide | Range of cardio machines, free weights, and strength-training equipment. Treadmills, ellipticals, and stationary bikes. They generally limit the number of bench presses and often ban squat racks. Dumbbells usually go up to 70-80 lbs. |
| Class Offerings | Cycling, running, strength training, yoga, meditation, HIIT, Pilates, barre, and outdoor workouts; live and on-demand classes | Group fitness classes, with a focus on low-cost, low-impact options. Common classes include yoga, Pilates, cycling, Zumba, and boot camp. Class offerings can vary by location. Free fitness training in small group formats. |
| Personal Training Options | Peloton Guide offers programs for strength training; Personalized Plans in beta | One-on-one personal training is generally not available. Group training sessions are offered. Certified fitness trainers lead small group fitness classes and can help you create a customized workout plan. |
| Contract Flexibility | Free trials available for the app; cancel trial at any time | You may be required to commit for 12 months. |
| Cleanliness and Maintenance | Wipe down after every ride; monthly deep cleaning advised; use gentle cleansers | Generally committed to maintaining clean facilities. Members often appreciate the regular cleaning and maintenance of equipment. |
| Location and Accessibility | At-home convenience; Peloton App allows access on various devices | Large number of locations (2,700+ worldwide). Many locations are open 24/7. |
| Crowdedness | Not applicable | Can get crowded during peak hours, especially around lunchtime and after work (4pm-7:30pm). Consider visiting during off-peak hours like late at night, early morning, or mid-day (10am-2pm). The PF App has a "Crowd Meter" to help you pick the best time to visit. |
| Ambiance and Atmosphere | Immersive experience through high-quality production, dynamic lighting, and motivational instructors | Aims for a "Judgment Free Zone," creating a relaxed and welcoming environment. The atmosphere is designed to be non-intimidating, appealing to beginners and casual gym-goers. |
| Customer Service Quality | Mixed reputation | Staff is often praised for friendliness and helpfulness. They offer a 24/7 support hotline and online resources. Planet Fitness has been recognized for customer service excellence. |
| Digital Integration (App, Tracking) | Integrates with Apple Watch and Fitbit; real-time metrics; app for tracking, booking, and social interaction | The PF App allows you to track activities, access on-demand workouts, and use the Crowd Meter. The app also offers free strength programs with workout videos and guides. |
| Community and Social Aspects | Strong community with leaderboards, group challenges, and social media sharing | Aims to create a supportive community. The "Judgment Free Zone" encourages members to feel comfortable. The Black Card membership allows you to bring a guest. |