Cosmetic brands: Kylie Cosmetics vs. Hourglass Cosmetics
Quick Verdict
Kylie Cosmetics offers a wider range of products at a mid-range price point with a fully vegan line, while Hourglass Cosmetics focuses on luxury with many vegan options.
- Kylie Cosmetics is fully vegan, while Hourglass Cosmetics offers many, but not all, vegan options.
- Hourglass Cosmetics is positioned as a luxury brand, while Kylie Cosmetics is considered mid-range.
- Both brands are cruelty-free, but Kylie Cosmetics is owned by a parent company that is not.
Key features – Side-by-Side
| Attribute | Kylie Cosmetics | Hourglass Cosmetics |
|---|---|---|
| Product Range | lip kits, lip glosses, highlighters, blushes, bronzers, eyeshadow palettes, concealers, skin tints, eyeliners, brow essentials, Kylie Skin, Kylie Baby lines | Complexion, color, and skincare items including foundations, concealers, blushes, highlighters, palettes, brushes, lip balms, lipsticks, mascaras, eyeliners, cleansers, serums, and eye balms |
| Cruelty-Free Status | Certified cruelty-free by PETA, owned by Coty (not cruelty-free) | Certified cruelty-free by PETA |
| Vegan Options Availability | 100% vegan | Not 100% vegan, but many products are produced without animal-derived ingredients |
| Price Point | Mid-range | Luxury brand |
| Packaging Quality | Aesthetically appealing and functional | Luxurious packaging using materials like PCR plastic, tin, and glass |
Overall Comparison
Vegan: Kylie wins; Price: Kylie more affordable; Cruelty-Free: Both certified, Kylie has non-cruelty-free parent
Pros and Cons
Kylie Cosmetics
Pros:
- Wide variety of makeup products
- Emphasis on clean ingredients
- Cruelty-free (certified by PETA)
- 100% vegan
- Vibrant and bold color options
- Long-lasting lip kits
- Super blendable matte liquid eyeshadows
- Aesthetically appealing and functional packaging
- Offers a wide range of hues to suit different skin types and shades
Cons:
- Parent company (Coty) is not cruelty-free
- Some reviewers found pigmentation lacking in certain products (e.g., blush)
- High gloss needs frequent reapplication
- Some describe packaging as cheap or tacky
- Some feel products are overpriced for the quality
- Some darker concealer shades had red undertones
- Customer service dissatisfaction
- Decline in popularity since 2016
Hourglass Cosmetics
Pros:
- Wide product range
- Cruelty-free
- High pigmentation
- Long-lasting wear
- Good blendability
- Luxurious packaging
- Suitable for different skin types
Cons:
- Not 100% vegan
- Some questionable ingredients
- Packaging durability issues reported
- High price point
- Inconsistent shade range
- Customer service issues reported
User Experiences and Feedback
Kylie Cosmetics
What Users Love
- Lip products last from 8 am to 10 pm without needing retouching
- Matte liquid eyeshadows feel almost weightless on the eyes
- New blush formula blends seamlessly
- Skin Tint is designed for long-lasting coverage for everyday wear
- Applicator of the eye cream is travel-friendly
Common Complaints
- Kylie Clarifying Cleansing Gel caused redness, swelling, and itchiness
- Some users find the high gloss sticky
- Some reviewers feel that the products are overpriced for the quality
Value Perception
- Some reviewers feel that the products are overpriced for the quality
User Recommendations
- The matte liquid eyeshadows are super blendable and comfortable on the eyes.
- The new blush formula is also praised for being more seamless and easier to blend.
- The brand aims to offer a wide range of hues to suit different skin types and shades.
Hourglass Cosmetics
What Users Love
- High-quality products
- Good performance
- Long-lasting wear
- Excellent blendability
- Luxurious feel
Common Complaints
- Shade range limitations
- Customer service issues
- Packaging durability concerns
- High price for the amount of product
Value Perception
- Quality justifies the cost for many users
- Some reviewers suggest more affordable alternatives exist