Fenty Beauty is a strong choice for those seeking a wide range of shades and coverage levels with long-wearing formulas, while Glossier is better suited for those who prefer a natural, dewy look with a focus on skincare and easy application. Consider skin sensitivity and ethical concerns when making a decision.
| Attribute | Fenty Beauty | Glossier |
|---|---|---|
| Product Range | Wide range of makeup products across face, eye, lip and cheek categories | Offers a range of makeup, skincare, body care, and fragrance products. |
| Shade Range | Up to 50 shades available, catering to a wide spectrum of skin tones and undertones | Expanded shade range for complexion products like Perfecting Skin Tint and Stretch Concealer to 12 shades. Increased shades for Wowder. Aims for flexible shades that suit multiple skin tones. |
| Cruelty-Free Status | Cruelty-free | Certified cruelty-free by Leaping Bunny. Doesn't test finished products or ingredients on animals, nor do their suppliers or third parties. |
| Vegan Options Availability | Not 100% vegan, but offers a wide selection of vegan products. Fenty Skin and Fenty Hair are fully vegan lines. | Not 100% vegan, but offers many vegan products, which are clearly marked on their website. |
| Packaging Sustainability | Working to reduce environmental impact by phasing out magnets, using recyclable materials, and offering refillable options | Offers a 'limited packaging' option without the pink pouch and stickers. Some products have refillable packaging or use recycled materials. Still relies on plastic packaging for many products. |
| Price Point | High-end brand, relatively expensive | Pricier than some alternatives. |
| Ingredient Quality | Formulated without gluten-derived ingredients, paraben-free, and phthalate-free. Some products contain talc, dimethicone, and phenoxyethanol. | Some products contain natural ingredients. Doesn't use certified organic ingredients. |
| Skin Sensitivity | Fenty Skin is designed to be suitable for all skin types. Some products contain fragrance, which can be irritating for sensitive skin. | Some reviewers with sensitive skin have had positive experiences. Others have reported irritation, breakouts, or allergic reactions. |
| Longevity and Wear Time | Pro Filt'r Soft Matte Longwear Foundation is designed for long wear. The Soft'Lit Naturally Luminous Longwear Foundation is designed to be long-wearing, waterproof, and transfer-resistant. | Some reviewers find that makeup lasts all day. Others have concerns about product longevity. |
| Coverage Level | Offers a range of coverage levels, from sheer to full | Complexion products generally offer sheer coverage. |
| Finish | Offers various finishes, including matte, dewy, and satin | Products often provide a dewy or luminous finish. |
| Brand Reputation and Customer Reviews | Generally well-regarded, particularly for its inclusive shade range and high-quality products. Some users have noted that certain products can be sticky or not as long-lasting as desired. | Strong brand reputation and a cult following. Reviews mention appealing scents and natural finishes. Some customers have raised concerns about inconsistent product quality and ethical issues. |