Clinics: NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital (New York, NY) vs. MD Anderson Cancer Center (Houston, TX)
Quick Verdict
Both hospitals are highly reputable, with NewYork-Presbyterian offering broader services and MD Anderson specializing in cancer care.
- NewYork-Presbyterian excels in a wide range of specialties and offers comprehensive language support.
- MD Anderson is the top-ranked cancer center with a large clinical trials program and advanced technologies.
- NewYork-Presbyterian has significantly more beds than MD Anderson.
Key features – Side-by-Side
| Attribute | NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital (New York, NY) | MD Anderson Cancer Center (Houston, TX) |
|---|---|---|
| Hospital Ranking (US News & World Report) | #1 in New York and #7 in the nation | #1 in the nation for cancer care for 11 consecutive years |
| Specialty Focus | Wide range of specialties, including cardiology, neurology, psychiatry, diabetes/endocrinology, rheumatology, cancer care, digestive diseases, and women's health | Comprehensive cancer center specializing in medical oncology and hematology |
| Availability of Clinical Trials | Over 2,000 clinical trials underway | Large clinical trials program with thousands of trials |
| Number of Beds | Over 2,600 beds; operates over 4,000 beds in total | 616 inpatient beds. 756 total staffed beds. 760 inpatient beds. |
| Insurance Acceptance | Accepts a wide array of insurance plans, including major commercial insurers, Medicare, and Medicaid | Accepts Medicare Parts A and B. Accepts Traditional Texas Medicaid. Limited participation in individual insurance plans. |
| Physician Expertise and Credentials | More than 6,500 affiliated physicians; affiliated with Columbia University Vagelos College of Physicians and Surgeons and Weill Cornell Medicine | Over 400 faculty members. Employs more than 1,700 faculty members. Recognized for nursing excellence with Magnet designations. |
| Language Support Services | Interpreters available in over 300 languages; sign language interpreting services available | Interpreters are available to assist patients whose native language is not English. Language assistance is available in multiple languages. |
Overall Comparison
Ranking: MD Anderson #1 in cancer, NYP #7 nationally; Specialties: NYP broad, MDA cancer-focused; Beds: NYP larger; Trials: Both offer many
Pros and Cons
NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital (New York, NY)
Pros:
- High overall patient satisfaction (89/100)
- High recommendation rate (90% would recommend)
- Top-ranked hospital in New York and nationally
- Wide range of specialties and clinical trials
- Comprehensive language support services
Cons:
- Waiting times for appointments can vary widely
- 77% of patients said that nurses 'Always' communicated well with patients
- 69% of patients said that their room and bathroom were 'Always' clean
MD Anderson Cancer Center (Houston, TX)
Pros:
- High quality of care
- Attentive and compassionate doctors and nurses
- Large clinical trials program
- Advanced technologies
- Language support services
- Specialized outpatient clinics
Cons:
- Difficulties in scheduling appointments and communication
- Facilities maintenance issues (cleanliness and comfort)
- High cost of treatment
- Wait times for appointments
User Experiences and Feedback
NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital (New York, NY)
What Users Love
- High patient satisfaction scores
- High recommendation rate
- Attentive doctors and nurses
- Cleanliness of rooms and bathrooms
Common Complaints
- No major complaints reported.
Value Perception
- No value feedback reported.
User Recommendations
- Patients gave an overall rating of 89 out of 100.
- 90% of patients reported that they would definitely recommend the hospital to others.
- 77% of patients said that nurses 'Always' communicated well with patients
- 81% said doctors 'Always' communicated well.
- 69% of patients said that their room and bathroom were 'Always' clean.
MD Anderson Cancer Center (Houston, TX)
What Users Love
- Praise for the quality of care
- Attentiveness and compassion of doctors and nurses
- Many reviews recommend MD Anderson
- Devoted to setting the standard in cancer patient care, research, education and prevention
Common Complaints
- Difficulties in scheduling appointments and communication
- Classrooms are not cleaned frequently and the restrooms are broken and smelly
Value Perception
- MD Anderson is not cheap but supposed to be the best in the world.
User Recommendations
- Many reviewers praise the quality of care.
- Many reviews highlight the attentiveness and compassion of the doctors and nurses.
- Many reviews recommend MD Anderson.