Max vs. Amazon Prime Video – Detailed Comparison

Quick Verdict

Max is suitable for users who prioritize a wide range of content, including live sports and 4K HDR, and don't mind paying a premium. Amazon Prime Video is a better option for those seeking a more affordable service with a vast library and are already Amazon Prime members, but be aware of the potential for ads and a less intuitive interface.

Key Specs – Side-by-Side

MetricMaxAmazon Prime Video
Price$9.99 - $20.99/month$8.99/month (standalone)
FeaturesSimultaneous Streams: Up to 4 devices, Offline Viewing: Up to 100 downloads, 4K HDR: On the monthly and yearly 'Ultimate Ad-free' plans, Bundles: Yes, Parental Controls: YesOffline Downloads: Offers mobile downloads for offline viewing, 4K Streaming: Streams in 4K Ultra HD and High Dynamic Range (HDR), Bundling Options: Allows you to add channels like Max, Paramount+, and Starz for an extra monthly fee, Free Trial: 30-day free membership trial, which includes access to Prime Video
Ratingoverall: 2.6/5, performance: Not availableoverall: Not available, performance: Not available

Overall Comparison

  • Max: Starting at $9.99/month, offers up to 4 simultaneous streams and 100 downloads, with 4K HDR on higher tiers.
  • Amazon Prime Video: Standalone subscription at $8.99/month, includes ads unless you pay extra, and offers 4K streaming and mobile downloads.

Pros and Cons

Max

Pros:
  • The app seems much cleaner and snappier than before
  • Extensive catalog of popular movies and TV shows
  • Ability to create up to 5 profiles, including a Kid's profile
  • Offers multiple plans to choose from
  • You can now watch live sports and news
  • The 'Ultimate Ad-Free' tier includes more content than HBO Max
  • Includes HBO originals, popular classics, live sports, and an expanded 4K content library
  • Well-designed apps
  • Offline downloads on ad-free tier
  • Great collection of popular film series
  • Smooth app experience on just about every device
Cons:
  • Prices are too high for what it provides
  • Content removal is baffling
  • Ad breaks on the cheapest plan
  • Comparatively expensive plans
  • Fewer restrictions are preferred on the ad-supported tier

Amazon Prime Video

Pros:
  • Wide variety of shows and movies, especially the exclusive content
  • Access to free Prime Reading (over 1,000 digital books)
  • Prime Music streaming (up to 40 hours of music each month)
  • Access to live sports programming (NFL, NBA, and WNBA coverage)
  • X-Ray feature shows info about actors and music while watching
Cons:
  • Interface can be cluttered and hard to navigate
  • Some users find it confusing to figure out what's free and what's not
  • Includes ads unless you pay extra

User Experiences and Feedback