AI-Powered Universal Comparison Engine

Car rental companies: National Car Rental vs. Budget

Quick Verdict

Both National Car Rental and Budget Rent a Car offer similar services with key differences in customer service consistency and loyalty program perks. National emphasizes vehicle cleanliness, while Budget focuses on competitive pricing. Consider your priorities and compare rates before booking.

Key features – Side-by-Side

AttributeNational Car RentalBudget
Rental car varietyCars, trucks, and vans
PriceVaries, compare rates from different companies
Customer service844-393-9989 (US), 844-307-8015 (Canada). Some reviews suggest exceptional customer service.
Pick-up processEmerald Club aims to make the rental experience faster and more convenient
Drop-off processDrop & Go service where you can drop off the car and go, receiving an emailed receipt
Vehicle cleanlinessComplete Clean Pledge to thoroughly clean vehicles between rentals, paying attention to high-touch points
Vehicle conditionPerforms a final quality check on every vehicle before each rental, including documenting the vehicle's condition
Extra feesDaily additional driver fee (averages $12 a day, may be waived). Additional cleaning fees may apply for excessive dirt or smoking
Loyalty program benefitsEmerald Club: Bypassing the counter, choosing your own car, earning rewards towards free rental days, no second driver fees, free upgrades in Europe
Geographic availabilityWorldwide, including the United States, Canada, Europe, Latin America, the Caribbean, Asia-Pacific, Africa, and Australia. 307 locations in the United States as of July 30, 2025
Insurance optionsDamage Waiver (DW), Personal Effects Coverage (PEC), Personal Accident Insurance (PAI), Roadside Assistance Protection (RAP), Supplemental Liability Insurance (SLI)
Online booking experienceNational Car Rental app allows you to manage rentals, locate facilities, and manage your Emerald Club profile

Overall Comparison

National Car Rental: 307 US locations. Budget Rent a Car: Over 2,000 branches globally. National Car Rental: Additional driver fee averages $12 a day.

Pros and Cons

National Car Rental

Pros:
  • Wide variety of vehicles (cars, trucks, vans)
  • Emerald Club loyalty program benefits
  • Convenient pick-up and drop-off processes (Emerald Club, Drop & Go)
  • Extensive geographic availability
  • Complete Clean Pledge for vehicle cleanliness
  • Online booking and management via app
Cons:
  • Prices vary, requiring comparison with other companies
  • Potential for unexpected or hidden fees
  • Additional driver fees
  • Additional cleaning fees may apply

Budget Rent a Car

Pros:
  • Wide variety of vehicles
  • Competitive rates
  • Fastbreak loyalty program benefits
  • Extensive geographic availability
  • User-friendly online booking process
Cons:
  • Inconsistent customer service
  • Potential for unexpected extra fees
  • Some rentals may be older vehicles with more wear and tear

User Experiences and Feedback