Bedding & mattresses: Saatva Classic Mattress vs. Casper Original Hybrid Mattress
Quick Verdict
Both are quality mattresses with different strengths; Saatva offers more customization and a longer warranty, while Casper focuses on cooling and zoned support.
- Saatva offers more firmness options and a longer trial period.
- Casper uses AirScape technology for enhanced cooling.
- Saatva has a lifetime warranty, while Casper has a 10-year limited warranty.
Key features – Side-by-Side
| Attribute | Saatva Classic Mattress | Casper Original Hybrid Mattress |
|---|---|---|
| Mattress Type | Innerspring (coil-on-coil, some classify as hybrid innerspring with memory foam) | Hybrid (foam and pocketed coils) |
| Firmness Level | Plush Soft (3/10), Luxury Firm (5-7/10, or 6/10), and Firm (8/10) | Medium-firm, around 6 out of 10. Some sources say 6.5 out of 10. |
| Thickness/Height | Available in 11.5 inches and 14.5 inches | 10.5 or 11 inches |
| Edge Support Quality | Generally excellent | Excellent, featuring a firm border to prevent sagging |
| Motion Isolation Performance | Not a strong point, responsive to movement | Moderate motion transfer. Some sources say low motion transfer. Individually wrapped coils help minimize motion transfer. |
| Cooling Technology & Breathability | Designed with breathability in mind, temperature neutral | AirScape™ technology with perforated foam for increased airflow. Hybrid design with coils also enhances airflow. |
| Warranty Length | Lifetime warranty | 10-year limited warranty |
| Trial Period Length | 365-night trial | 100 nights. A 30-night adjustment period is required before returns. |
Overall Comparison
Firmness: Saatva more options; Cooling: Casper AirScape; Warranty: Saatva lifetime vs Casper 10yr
Pros and Cons
Saatva Classic Mattress
Pros:
- Customization options (firmness, height)
- Balance of comfort and support
- Durable construction
- Good edge support
- Breathable and sleeps cool
- Lumbar support and spinal alignment features
- Free white glove delivery
- Easy exchanges/returns
- Minimal off-gassing
Cons:
- Motion isolation is not a strong point
- Firmness perception can be subjective
Casper Original Hybrid Mattress
Pros:
- Suitable for various sleeping positions (side, back, stomach, and combination)
- Provides a balance of comfort and support
- Strong edge support due to a firmer border
- Designed with cooling features like AirScape™ foam and a coil system to promote airflow and reduce heat retention
- Zoned Support™ helps align the spine and relieve pressure, which can be beneficial for back pain
- Casper is known for easy returns and customer service
- Hybrid construction with coils and high-density foams is expected to last for several years
Cons:
- Motion isolation is moderate
- Some initial off-gassing smell may be present, which can take up to 15 days to dissipate
User Experiences and Feedback
Saatva Classic Mattress
What Users Love
- Helps alleviate back and joint pain
- Comfortable for various sleeping positions (with appropriate firmness selection)
- Durable after several months of use
- Good customer service
Common Complaints
- May feel partner's movements
Value Perception
- No value feedback reported.
User Recommendations
- Luxury Firm model is often rated around 7.5 out of 10, which is firmer than the industry standard for medium-firm.
- The Saatva Classic is designed to sleep cool, thanks to its breathable cover and coil construction that allows for airflow. It is temperature neutral.
- Edge support is generally considered excellent, with sturdy edges that don't sag excessively.
Casper Original Hybrid Mattress
What Users Love
- Recommended for those with similar sleeping preferences and needs, particularly if they want a balance of comfort, support, and cooling.
Common Complaints
- No major complaints reported.
Value Perception
- No value feedback reported.