Proof Bakery is a great choice for those seeking artisan breads and European-style sandwiches in Los Angeles, while Magnolia Bakery is ideal for classic American desserts and cakes with multiple locations and friendly service. Your choice depends on your location, preference for bread versus classic desserts, and desired customer service experience.
| Attribute | Proof Bakery | Magnolia Bakery |
|---|---|---|
| Name | Proof Bakery | Magnolia Bakery |
| Bread Variety | Artisan sourdough, country white, marbled rye, multi-seed, Italian focaccia, stirato (Italian baguette), challah, babka, Stecca bread sandwiches | Not available |
| Pastry Selection | Classic butter croissants, chocolate croissants, almond croissants, kouign amann, seasonal fruit danish, blueberry muffins, lemon poppy seed muffins, cinnamon rolls, pain au raisin, financiers, canel de Bordeaux, maple pecan scones, ham & cheese croissants, quiche Lorraine, mushroom & thyme quiche, avocado tartine, smoked salmon tartine, spinach & feta scones | Offers a range of pastries |
| Cake Options | Fromage Blanc Cheesecake, Chocolate Mousse Cake, G teau de Savoie, Strawberry Malt Cake, Chocolate Devil's Food Cake, Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting, Classic Lemon Tart | Confetti Cake, Chocolate Cake, Vanilla Cake, Hummingbird Cake, Red Velvet Cake, custom cake orders |
| Gluten-Free Options | Buckwheat chocolate chip cookie | Flourless chocolate cake, gluten-free banana pudding |
| Vegan Options | Seasonal vegan sandwich | Some cakes can be made vegan |
| Coffee Quality | Artisan coffee from West Coast roasters (Cognoscenti Coffee), coffee, cold brew, espresso, Americano, cappuccino, latte, mocha, hot chocolate, chai latte, hojicha latte, fresh squeezed orange juice | Coffee is available |
| Sandwich Offerings | European-style sandwiches on Stecca bread: salami, manchego & chive butter, beet, arugula & goat cheese, ham with heirloom tomatoes, gruyere & grainy mustard. Daily options: turkey, salami, cheese, vegan | Not available |
| Custom Cake Orders | Minimum purchase and advance notice required | Yes, for cakes and cupcakes |
| Price Range | Croissants: $4.50-$6.75, Sandwiches: ~$9.50, Whole cakes: $58-$62 | Higher end; cupcake ~$4.15, cakes start at ~$60 |
| Ambiance and Seating | Rustic charm, bustling, cozy ambiance, limited seating, some outdoor seating | Cozy and inviting space with a nostalgic decor |
| Customer Service | Mixed reviews: some staff super friendly and helpful, others noted as rude | Friendly and helpful staff |
| Location and Accessibility | Atwater Village, Los Angeles. Easy to access, parking can be tight during busy times | Multiple locations in New York City and beyond |
| Ratings | Not available | Value for money and ROI score of 3.6 out of 5 stars |