AI-Powered Universal Comparison Engine

Auto loans: myAutoloan.com vs. PenFed Credit Union Auto Loan

Quick Verdict

PenFed Credit Union Auto Loan generally offers more competitive rates and better customer service options, making it a strong choice for those who qualify and don't need private-party or lease buyout loans. MyAutoloan.com is a good option for those who need a wider variety of loan types or who do not qualify for PenFed membership or rates.

Key features – Side-by-Side

AttributemyAutoloan.comPenFed Credit Union Auto Loan
APR Range (New Auto Loans)Starting from 6.49%As low as 3.79% (with PenFed Car Buying Service), otherwise starting at 4.59%
APR Range (Used Auto Loans)Starting from 6.74%Starting at 4.99%
APR Range (Refinance Auto Loans)Starting from 4.95%Not specified
APR Range (Lease Buyout Loans)Starting from 4.59%Not specified
APR Range (Private Party Auto Loans)Starting from 6.49%Not specified
Loan Amounts (New and Used Auto Loans)Starting at $8,000Up to $150,000
Loan Amounts (Refinance Auto Loans)Starting at $5,000Not specified
Loan Terms (Months)24 to 72 months (up to 84 months for new car and refinance loans with some lenders)36 to 84 months
Minimum Credit Score Required600661 or higher may help qualify for better rates and terms; 720 or higher preferable for best rates
Pre-Qualification OptionYes, with a soft credit checkYes, with a soft credit check
Discount for AutopayLess than half of lending partners offer up to 0.25%No rate discount
Origination FeeNone charged by myAutoloan.comNo origination fees
Prepayment PenaltyNot specifiedNo prepayment penalties
Processing FeesLending partners may charge processing feesNot specified
Types of Vehicles FinancedNew, used, refinance, private-party, and lease buyoutNew, used, and refinance (no RV or motorcycle loans)
Maximum Vehicle AgeGenerally 10 years or newer; new cars should not be older than current model year minus oneNo maximum age for used vehicles (vehicle must be no older than five years for 84-month loan term)
Maximum MileageGenerally 125,000 miles (100,000 for refinance)125,000 miles (less than 60,000 miles for 84-month loan term)
AvailabilityAvailable in 48 states (not in Alaska or Hawaii)Nationwide
Customer Service ChannelsContact form and FAQ section (no phone number listed)Online, in person at a PenFed branch, or by phone at 800-247-5626

Overall Comparison

PenFed Credit Union Auto Loan offers APRs as low as 3.79% for new cars, while myAutoloan.com starts at 4.59% for lease buyout loans. MyAutoloan.com is available in 48 states, while PenFed Credit Union Auto Loan provides nationwide availability.

Pros and Cons

myAutoloan.com

Pros:
  • Wide range of loan options (new, used, refinance, private-party, lease buyout)
  • Pre-qualification option available with a soft credit check
  • Online application process
  • Rate estimator tool available on website
  • No origination fee charged by myAutoloan.com
Cons:
  • Availability limited to 48 states (not available in Alaska or Hawaii)
  • No phone number listed for customer service
  • Lending partners may charge processing fees
  • APR discount for autopay not offered by all lending partners (less than half)
  • Actual APR depends on credit score, loan amount, and lender policies

PenFed Credit Union Auto Loan

Pros:
  • Pre-qualification available with a soft credit check
  • No origination fees
  • No prepayment penalties
  • Easy online application process
  • Nationwide availability
Cons:
  • No rate discount for automatic payments
  • No RV or motorcycle loans
  • Internal refinancing of existing PenFed auto loans not permitted

User Experiences and Feedback