AI-Powered Universal Comparison Engine

Auto loans: Carvana Auto Financing vs. Capital One Auto Navigator

Quick Verdict

Carvana Auto Financing is more accessible to individuals with lower credit scores and offers a fully online experience, but it has a higher potential APR and is limited to Carvana vehicle purchases. Capital One Auto Navigator requires a slightly better credit score for optimal rates and involves finalizing the loan at a participating dealership, but it offers a wider range of loan terms and refinancing options.

Key features – Side-by-Side

AttributeCarvana Auto FinancingCapital One Auto Navigator
Minimum Credit Score RequiredNoneApprovals reported as low as 500, aim for above 660 for best rates
Interest Rates (APR) Range3.99% to 27.99%5.99% to 17.99% as of May 2025. New auto loans APRs start at 5.50% for 60-month terms and 5.67% for 72-month terms. Used auto loans APRs start at 6.04% for 60-month terms and 6.43% for 72-month terms.
Loan Amounts Available$1,000 to $125,000Minimum $4,000 for auto purchase loans. Refinance loans range from $7,500 to $75,000. Maximum loan amounts for purchase loans are not disclosed.
Loan Terms (Months)12 to 72 months (up to 78 months for higher credit customers)24 to 84 months
Pre-qualification Option AvailableYesYes, through Auto Navigator with a soft credit check
Down Payment RequirementsUsually required, amount variesRequired in some situations
Fees (Origination, Prepayment, etc.)Origination: None, Late Payment: $5, Prepayment: None, Shipping/Delivery: May applyNo prepayment penalty. Potential dealer fees: documentation, reconditioning, advertising, sales tax, extended warranty. Origination fee not explicitly mentioned.
Vehicle Age RestrictionsMaximum 10 yearsUsed cars generally need to be within 10 model years
Vehicle Mileage RestrictionsMaximum 200,000 milesGenerally less than 120,000 miles
Co-signer Option AvailableYes, in select statesYes
Application Process (Online, In-Person)100% onlinePrimarily online through Auto Navigator, finalize at participating dealership
Funding Speed (Time to Receive Loan)As soon as one dayPotentially available as soon as the same day

Overall Comparison

Carvana: No minimum credit score, APR 3.99%-27.99%, Loan Amounts $1,000-$125,000. Capital One: Minimum credit score ~500, APR 5.99%-17.99%, Loan Amounts min $4,000.

Pros and Cons

Carvana Auto Financing

Pros:
  • No minimum credit score required
  • Pre-qualification available with soft credit check
  • No origination or prepayment fees
  • Co-signer option available in select states
  • 100% online application process
  • Funds may be available as soon as one day
  • Clean Vehicle Tax Credit eligibility
Cons:
  • APRs can be high (up to 27.99%)
  • Down payment usually required
  • Shipping and delivery fees may apply
  • Late payment fee of $5
  • Loans can only be used for Carvana vehicle purchases
  • Limited information on dispute resolution process

Capital One Auto Navigator

Pros:
  • Pre-qualification available with soft credit check
  • No prepayment penalty
  • Co-signer option available
  • Auto loan refinancing available
Cons:
  • Down payment required in some situations
  • Potential hidden fees from the dealer (documentation, reconditioning, advertising)
  • Limited to participating dealerships
  • Vehicle restrictions (certain makes, commercial vehicles, motorcycles, RVs, etc.)
  • Not available in Alaska and Hawaii
  • Pre-qualification is not a guarantee of final approval
  • Customer service issues reported in some reviews

User Experiences and Feedback