Compare Products, Services & More

Alcoholic beverages: Natural Wine vs. Ready-to-Drink Cocktails (Cutwater Spirits, High Noon)

Quick Verdict

Natural wine offers a unique, artisanal experience with a focus on natural processes and distinct flavors, while ready-to-drink cocktails provide convenience, consistency, and a variety of familiar flavors. Cutwater Spirits stands out with its diverse cocktail range and higher ABV, while High Noon emphasizes refreshing fruit flavors and lower calories.

Key features – Side-by-Side

AttributeNatural WineReady-to-Drink Cocktails (Cutwater Spirits, High Noon)
Flavor ProfileFunkier, gamier, yeastier characteristics. Less fruity and more yeasty, sometimes smelling like yogurt or German Hefeweizen. Some may have sour notes. Flavors can range from light and juicy to bold and earthy. Often exhibit a lively, "raw" character.
Alcohol Content (ABV)Typically between 10% and 14%, some natural wines can have higher or lower levels (typically less than 12.5% by volume).
IngredientsEssentially fermented grape juice. In its purest form, it contains no additives.
Production MethodGrapes are typically hand-picked from organic or biodynamic vineyards. Fermentation occurs with no added yeast (native yeasts). Little to no sulfites are added. Often unfiltered.
Sweetness LevelProduced across the dryness/sweetness spectrum.
Organic/Biodynamic CertificationGrapes must be harvested manually from a vineyard managed by either organic practice or under biodynamic principles. Look for labels such as Demeter or Biodyvin.
Presence of SulfitesMinimal or no added sulfites are used. Typically contain 10-35 parts per million (ppm) of sulfites, compared to 350 ppm in regular wines.
Packaging TypeVarious formats, from glass bottles to cans. Tetra Paks are also used.
Serving SizeA standard serving of wine is a 5 oz glass.
Calorie Count per ServingA standard 5 oz glass of wine contains around 120 to 130 calories. A glass of Pet Nat with 12% alcohol has around 100 calories.
Brand ReputationDriven by consumers who demand "transparency and truth around the winemaking process". Authenticity of the final product is key.
Price PointCeramic wine bottles are unique and limited products, driving the cost up and making the wines far more expensive.

Overall Comparison

Natural Wine: ABV typically 10-14%, Sulfites 10-35 ppm, Calories 120-130 per 5oz serving. Ready-to-Drink Cocktails: Cutwater Spirits ABV 5.9-13%, Price $3-4/can, High Noon ABV 4.5%, 100 calories/serving, Price $19/8-pack.

Pros and Cons

Natural Wine

Pros:
  • Unique taste experience due to the exclusion of chemicals and additives
  • Allows the natural aromas of the grapes to develop
  • Offers varied aromatic profiles according to soil, grape variety, and vintage
  • Aluminum cans are more eco-friendly than traditional glass bottles
  • Bag-in-box wine has a lower carbon footprint compared to glass bottles
Cons:
  • Can vary widely in taste even between bottles of the same type
  • Natural wines are famous for being a bit unusual
  • Ceramic wine bottles are unique and limited products, driving the cost up and making the wines far more expensive

Ready-to-Drink Cocktails (Cutwater Spirits, High Noon)

Pros:
  • Cutwater Spirits: Diverse flavor range, authentic and balanced flavors, higher ABV compared to typical canned seltzers, good value for the quality and convenience, convenient for portability.
  • High Noon: Clean, refreshing, authentic fruit flavors, less sweet than competitors, convenient and easy to pack, well-priced for the flavor and ingredients.
Cons:
  • Cutwater Spirits: Overconsumption of higher ABV drinks could lead to typical alcohol-related effects.
  • High Noon: Environmental impact not specified.

User Experiences and Feedback