Both Adobe Firefly AI and RunwayML Gen-3 are powerful tools for image and video generation, each with its strengths. Adobe Firefly AI is a great option for users already familiar with the Adobe ecosystem and those looking for seamless integration and ease of use. RunwayML Gen-3 is better suited for users who prioritize hyper-realistic video generation, advanced control over video elements, and consistent character generation. The choice between the two depends on specific project requirements, budget considerations, and the user's existing workflow.
| Attribute | Adobe Firefly AI | RunwayML Gen-3 |
|---|---|---|
| Image Generation Quality | Offers photorealistic images with lifelike details and lighting, as well as artistic interpretations with preset styles. Includes Structure Reference and Style Reference features. | Powers Runway's Text-to-Image tools, stylistic control and visual fidelity. |
| Video Generation Capabilities | Features text-to-video generation, image-to-video generation, camera angle control, camera motion control, shot type control, and atmospheric elements. Employs newer algorithms for smoother and more lifelike motion. | Creates hyper-realistic videos with smooth motion and coherent human models, high-resolution, detailed, and consistent videos with impressive speed and precision, realistic movements, including complex actions like running and walking, generate special effects and styles, generate videos in slow motion. |
| Prompt Accuracy and Control | Translates text and other inputs into results, understanding detailed instructions about style, content, and composition. Allows adjustment of parameters such as camera angle, motion, and aspect ratio in video generation. | Trained with highly descriptive, temporally dense captions, style presets and prompt modifiers, camera movement, establishing the scene, and additional details. |
| Image Editing Features | Includes Generative Fill for erasing distractions, filling gaps, removing unwanted elements, and enhancing specific areas. Also features Generative Expand. | AI-powered tools for image creation and enhancement. |
| Video Editing Features | Incorporates tools for precise manipulation of generated content, including augmented control over components, time modifications, and visual designs. | Background removal, color grading, face blurring, style transfer capability, video-to-video feature. |
| Integration with Existing Creative Workflows | Integrates with Adobe Creative Suite tools like Lightroom, Premiere Pro, and Adobe Express. Supports third-party integrations including OpenAI's GPT-4o, Google's Imagen 3 and Veo 2, and Black Forest Labs' Flux 1.1 Pro. | Access inside Gen-3 Alpha and the Runway API. |
| Ease of Use and Learning Curve | Designed to be beginner-friendly with a user-friendly interface. | Updated user interface designed for both beginners and professionals. |
| Customization Options | Allows organizations to fine-tune generative AI models with their own assets (10 to 20 images). Users can adjust visual intensity and strength settings. | Stylistically controlled and consistent characters, motion brush, advanced camera controls, and director mode. |
| Pricing | Starting from $9.99/month for separate access to AI video, image, and vector tools. Standard plan: $9.99/month (2,000 credits). Pro plan: $29.99 monthly. Premium option available. | Starts at $12/month, credits can be purchased in bundles starting at 1,000 credits which cost $10, or 1 cent per credit, available plans include Standard, Pro, and Unlimited. |
| Commercial Usage Rights | Content created with generative AI features can be used for commercial use unless the product is in beta and it says it cannot be used for commercial use. Trained on licensed content, such as Adobe Stock, and public domain content. | 10 credits per second of video generated. |