Both Salesforce Einstein AI Ethics Framework and DeepMind Ethics & Society Research Program demonstrate a strong commitment to ethical AI principles. Salesforce offers concrete tools and compliance measures, making it suitable for businesses seeking practical implementation. DeepMind focuses on research and broader societal implications, making it valuable for those interested in the ethical development and deployment of AI at a larger scale.
| Attribute | Salesforce Einstein AI Ethics Framework | DeepMind Ethics & Society Research Program |
|---|---|---|
| Ethical AI Framework Transparency | Ensures AI models and decision-making processes are explainable and interpretable, providing insights into how AI arrives at recommendations. | DeepMind emphasizes transparency in its AI ethics research and funding. They aim to conduct open research and investigation into the implications of their work. |
| Bias Detection and Mitigation Techniques | Employs rigorous testing, fairness audits, diverse datasets, and bias detection tools to identify and mitigate biases in AI models. Adjusts training data and implements algorithms that enforce fairness constraints. | DeepMind is actively working on AI safety and ethics, developing principles and systems to anticipate and address AI-related risks. They study how AI can replicate human biases and aim to prevent these biases from being built into their AI systems. They also develop algorithms to detect biased datasets. |
| Stakeholder Engagement Processes | Collaborates with external experts, industry partners, and its Research & Insights team. Seeks and leverages feedback for continuous improvement. | DeepMind engages with diverse stakeholders, including governments, civil society, researchers, and other organizations, to address AI-related challenges. They have collaborated with Involve to host roundtables for collaborative conversations between stakeholders on ethical questions raised by AI. |
| Accountability Mechanisms | Encourages responsibility for AI-driven decisions and emphasizes audit trails and human oversight. Establishes clear chains of responsibility and implements monitoring systems. | DeepMind established an AI ethics board after being acquired by Google, though the members are not public. The Responsibility and Safety Council (RSC) evaluates Google DeepMind's research, projects, and collaborations against AI Principles. |
| Explainability and Interpretability Methods | Ensures AI-driven decisions are explainable by providing insights into how AI arrives at recommendations. Techniques like LIME and SHAP are used to visualize the factors influencing model predictions. | DeepMind has published methods to evaluate explainability. Explainable AI (XAI) is a field of research that explores methods to provide humans with intellectual oversight over AI algorithms and make the reasoning behind AI decisions more understandable and transparent. |
| Data Privacy and Security Measures | Implements differential privacy techniques to anonymize data and limits data retention periods. The Einstein Trust Layer enhances data privacy and ensures secure AI interactions, ensuring compliance with regulations like GDPR and CCPA. | Google DeepMind recognizes the critical importance of safeguarding user security and privacy and invests in mitigations to limit the potential for misuse. They aim to invest in privacy-preserving infrastructure and models. |
| Human Oversight and Control | Emphasizes human oversight for AI-driven decisions, especially when they impact customer outcomes. Agentforce is designed to work alongside human teams, ensuring clear handoff protocols and oversight mechanisms. | DeepMind starts from the premise that all AI applications should remain under meaningful human control and be used for socially beneficial purposes. They are exploring ideas like having AIs learn human values to ensure that future intelligent systems remain under human control. |
| Fairness and Non-Discrimination Assessments | Ensures that AI systems treat all customers equally, avoiding any discriminatory outcomes. Uses diverse datasets and conducts bias audits. | DeepMind's ethics research focuses on how AI can improve people's lives and how to build more fair and equal societies. They also analyze the potential positive and negative effects of artificial intelligence on queer communities. |
| Impact Assessment Methodologies | Evaluates the system's impact on all stakeholders to ensure benefits or, at the very least, no disadvantage to customers, employees, partners, and the broader community. | DeepMind uses a three-layered framework for evaluating the social and ethical risks of AI systems, including evaluations of AI system capability, human interaction, and systemic impacts. |
| Ethical AI Training and Education Programs | Offers training and education on ethical AI principles for developers and users. Provides training modules on Responsible Creation of AI and Ethics by Design via Trailhead. | DeepMind provides AI and ethics training to every new DeepMind employee. They also work with schools and universities to support teachers, develop learning materials, and integrate AI into classrooms. |
| Compliance with AI Ethics Standards | Integrates privacy-first AI models and provides tools for businesses to manage customer data securely, ensuring compliance with regulations like GDPR and CCPA. | DeepMind is guided by its AI Principles and works to anticipate and evaluate its systems against a broad spectrum of AI-related risks. |
| Resource Allocation for Ethical AI Research | Established the SFDC AI Research team in 2014 and created the Office of Ethical and Humane Use of Technology to oversee the ethical implications of its technology. | In October 2017, DeepMind announced a new research unit, DeepMind Ethics & Society, to fund external research on themes like privacy, transparency, fairness, economic impacts, governance, accountability, AI risk, morality, values, and how AI can address global challenges. |
| Price | Not available | Not available |
| Ratings | Not available | Not available |